• Welcome to Camera Craniums: The Photography Community for Enthusiasts.

Recent Posts

Members
Stats
  • Total Posts: 62,515
  • Total Topics: 5,735
  • Online today: 33
  • Online ever: 6,071 (March 12, 2026, 03:28:52 AM)
Users Online
  • Users: 0
  • Guests: 7
  • Total: 7
bhphotovideo
What made you feel good t...Weekly CompetitionsCanon kit to borrow (free...Dreaminess Happy Christmas 2025!NiceVeedi 2-Pack Photogra...DJI Osmo Action 6 Essenti...RØDE Wireless ME Ultra-co...NEEWER Snap On ND Filter ...BRDRC Pocket 3 Camera Bik...Lenovo LOQ | 15.6 inch Fu...DJI Mic 3 (2 TX + 1 RX + ...DJI Mic Mini (2 TX + 1 RX...DJI OSMO Action 5 Pro 4 3...DJI Osmo Action 5 Pro Adv...Post your best shots here

Cheating or not?

Started by irv_b, December 19, 2009, 09:35:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Nemesis

Quote from: Oldboy on January 20, 2010, 02:13:36 PM
The use of the word likely stops them been sued. Mind you, when it was posted in a blog on photoradar, I did object that the photographer had used an remote setup and wasn't even present when it was taken. The whole point of wildlife photography is to be there to take the photo otherwise, where do you draw the line.  :o
I recall making similar comment on the olde DCM forums over a previous competition winner of the snow leopard taken with a triggered remote set up - I also recall being in the minority viewpoint.  OK in that case the photographer had done some field work to establish where a wild leopard was likely to travel, but instinct still tells me this wolf pic was staged with a tame/trained animal.

Oldboy

Quote from: Nemesis on January 20, 2010, 02:26:42 PM
Quote from: Oldboy on January 20, 2010, 02:13:36 PM
The use of the word likely stops them been sued. Mind you, when it was posted in a blog on photoradar, I did object that the photographer had used an remote setup and wasn't even present when it was taken. The whole point of wildlife photography is to be there to take the photo otherwise, where do you draw the line.  :o
I recall making similar comment on the olde DCM forums over a previous competition winner of the snow leopard taken with a triggered remote set up - I also recall being in the minority viewpoint.  OK in that case the photographer had done some field work to establish where a wild leopard was likely to travel, but instinct still tells me this wolf pic was staged with a tame/trained animal.

Quite agree, as a wild animal is more likely to squeeze through the gate unless persued by a pack of dogs.  ::)

Forseti

#17
Quote from: Oldboy on January 20, 2010, 02:13:36 PM

The use of the word likely stops them been sued.

Sued for what exactly? The photographer either cheated (for which they have irrefutable proof) or they are not absolutely sure in which case they should have let things stand. It' like saying that it's likely to rain which doesn't mean that it definitely will rain. A bit like your likely it will snow - only it didn't  :2funny: I won't comment on either the quality of the image or the manner in which it was captured as this is not the issue in point.

Edit: and if they are wrong and this is a slight on the photographers good name then they should be sued.
Canon 7D,  Canon SX1 IS, EF100 f/2.8 USM Macro, EF70-200 f/4 L IS USM, EF17-40 f/4 L USM, Sigma 50mm f/1.4 EX DG HSM, Canon Speedlite 580EX MkII

"Everyone can take a great picture with digital, the knack is to take two" - David Bailey

Oldboy

Quote from: Forseti on January 20, 2010, 02:42:13 PM
Quote from: Oldboy on January 20, 2010, 02:13:36 PM

The use of the word likely stops them been sued.

Sued for what exactly? The photographer either cheated (for which they have irrefutable proof) or they are not absolutely sure in which case they should have left things stand. It' like saying that it's likely to rain which doesn't mean that it definitely will rain. I won't comment on either the quality of the image or the manner in which it was captured as this is not the issue in point.

Edit: and if they are wrong and this is a slight on the photographers good name then they should be sued.

If they call him a cheat then they would need a cast iron case to prove it. Using the word likely raises doubts about the photo and the information provided by the photographer. Reading between the lines, I guess the photographer can't or won't provide proof that the image was taken within the rules of the competition.   8)

Forseti

Canon 7D,  Canon SX1 IS, EF100 f/2.8 USM Macro, EF70-200 f/4 L IS USM, EF17-40 f/4 L USM, Sigma 50mm f/1.4 EX DG HSM, Canon Speedlite 580EX MkII

"Everyone can take a great picture with digital, the knack is to take two" - David Bailey

Jonathan

Quote from: Oldboy on January 20, 2010, 03:22:55 PM
If they call him a cheat then they would need a cast iron case to prove it. Using the word likely raises doubts about the photo and the information provided by the photographer. Reading between the lines, I guess the photographer can't or won't provide proof that the image was taken within the rules of the competition.   8)

It's simple.  Put up or shut up.

Like Forsetti I'm not going to comment on the image (in fact I have already and my opinion stands) but if this were me and the magazine couldn't prove (as in "prove in a court of law") that I had cheated I would right now be talking to a lawyer about a defamation case.  Especially if I'd cheated ;)

[ETA: just read Mark Cawardine's explanation - doesn't change what I'd do one bit.  His reputation is now ruined.  And if they can't prove he did it they had better be ready to pay for that.]
It's Guest's round

magicrhodes

Quote
[ETA: just read Mark Cawardine's explanation - doesn't change what I'd do one bit.  His reputation is now ruined.  And if they can't prove he did it they had better be ready to pay for that.]
Quote


Why is his reputation ruined?

Jonathan

Quote from: magicrhodes on January 20, 2010, 04:12:41 PM
Quote
[ETA: just read Mark Cawardine's explanation - doesn't change what I'd do one bit.  His reputation is now ruined.  And if they can't prove he did it they had better be ready to pay for that.]
Quote


Why is his reputation ruined?

Because he appears to be a professional wildlife photographer.  He has been judged guilty of lying about his work.
It's Guest's round

magicrhodes

Quote from: Jonathan on January 20, 2010, 04:16:13 PM
Quote from: magicrhodes on January 20, 2010, 04:12:41 PM
Quote
[ETA: just read Mark Cawardine's explanation - doesn't change what I'd do one bit.  His reputation is now ruined.  And if they can't prove he did it they had better be ready to pay for that.]
Quote


Why is his reputation ruined?

Because he appears to be a professional wildlife photographer.  He has been judged guilty of lying about his work.

You mean El Spaniard and not Mark? I thought you were saying Mark's was ruined... hence my question

Jonathan

Ah no.  Mark's a mate of Douglas Adams.  His reputation is sacrosanct.
It's Guest's round

Jonathan

You know, the more I think about this, the odder it seems.

Somebody "owns" Ossian, somebody controls access to Canada Real.  So if this is what the judges suggest it is then somebody knows that a photographer came along there at night, set up his kit and got the wolf to jump over the fence.  Why is this all "he says, she says"?  If it's a fake then somebody else knows it.  He's still denying it so must be reasonably confident that no such person will come forward.

Interesting.......
It's Guest's round

greypoint

If it was taken elsewhere surely it would be easy enough for the photographer to prove it by simply giving the location or taking someone there....or have I missed something. On the other hand if it was the captive wolf....yes, how could he have taken the picture at Canada Real without anyone else knowing and coming forward.

picsfor

As a slight aside - why is it that there is now "no winner"?
Surely if he is disqualified he must hand back any prize money etc - which should in turn be given to the 2nd place picture.

A point has been made earlier in this thread about his ability to prove the authenticity of the picture. If he has failed to provide authenticity when requested - he has opened himself up for negative thinking.
Would any one here not have multiple copies of a picture they'd entered for such a prestigious competition - or any competition for that matter?

Something is not right about the photographers apparent inability or refusal to provide adequate proof of where the picture was taken etc.
I would like to think he will come forth and clear his name - but i'm not putting any bets on it. Sadly  :-\

picsfor

Quote from: Jonathan on January 20, 2010, 04:34:59 PM
Ah no.  Mark's a mate of Douglas Adams.  His reputation is sacrosanct.
The late Douglas Adams - author of Hitchhikers Guide etc...?


This website is proudly hosted on Crocweb Cloud Website Hosting.


Camera Craniums is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Program. This affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to products on Amazon.