cameracraniums.com

User Galleries

Click to view full size image

Winterwonderland

Used ND4 and pola filter. Sky to much? Always eager for feedbacks +/-

TurtagroII~0.jpg Undredal II.jpg Undredal.jpg Winterwonderland.jpg Wreck~0.jpg
File information
Filename:Winterwonderland.jpg
Album name:Jan Hagen / Landscapes
Rating (2 votes):8888888888
Keywords:Snow, / mountain, / cold
Critique Welcome, Yes / No:Yes
Filesize:419 KiB
Date added:Jan 20, 2010
Dimensions:1280 x 849 pixels
Displayed:145 times
Color Space:sRGB
Digital Zoom Ratio:1
EXIF Image Height:996 pixels
EXIF Image Width:1500 pixels
Exposure Mode:1
Exposure Program:Manual
Exposure Time:1/20 sec
FNumber:f/14
Flash:No Flash
Focal length:10 mm
Gain Control:0
ISO:200
Make:Nikon Corporation
Metering Mode:Pattern
Model:NIKON D300
Resolution Unit:Inch
Saturation:0
Scene Capture Mode:0
Software:Adobe Photoshop Elements 8.0 Macintosh
Y Resolution:240 dots per ResolutionUnit
URL:https://cameracraniums.com/gallery/displayimage.php?pid=5394
Favorites:Add to Favorites
BBCode normal size:
BBCode full size:

Comment 1 to 12 of 12
Page: 1

irv_b   [Jan 20, 2010 at 09:44 PM]
Sorry Jan to blue for me! the snow makes it look as though your wb is out, the branches in the top left distract the eye and the dark patch of the sky with no clouds to break it up doesn't help - sorry
Jan Hagen   [Jan 20, 2010 at 09:54 PM]
Thanks for your comments, Irv. Posted the same picture on another website, and looked even worse there. Agree with the patch, but the snow has a certain blue tone to it in the shadows. I could correct it more!? Cheers!
Oldboy   [Jan 20, 2010 at 11:13 PM]
Strange, as I think it's a cracking shot and the snow would look more blue at that time of day. Love the light on the mountains and the way the shot is framed. Very Happy
Tringle WP   [Jan 21, 2010 at 06:30 AM]
I agree with Irv I'm afraid. Too blue and too dark - uncalibrated monitor perhpas? Too blue and too bright is often manufacturers' default settings. Beautiful scene Jan. The thing is you'll never please everyone, the question is do you like it? If so, then it's perfect. Wink
Jan Hagen   [Jan 21, 2010 at 09:14 AM]
Thanks guys for your time and feedback. I agree with Oldboy, that there is a certain blue taint to the scene at this afternoon hour, but I'm really not pleased with the dark patch. Am I overdoing it with both a pola filter and a NDgrad4 filter. Maybe just the ND? Cheers Jan
Tringle WP   [Jan 21, 2010 at 10:19 AM]
If you still have access to the location why not pop out and try it with different combinations?
picsfor   [Jan 21, 2010 at 04:55 PM]
I rather like this. I like the blue tones which are actually a true rperesentation of snow at certain times of the day, and i also like the branches top left as they stop the plain becoming flat. What would also be interesting is to see this scene after getting the IR treatment because tha sky certainly looks like it could use it.
wiganbloke   [Jan 21, 2010 at 05:36 PM]
I can see some of the points mentioned before and can agree somewhat with them. However, Snow on a sunny day will have a blue tinge, I noticed this for the first time the other day out walking in the stuff. The dark blue in the centre is more than likely your polarizing filter, I've taken mine off because I had so many images with the same effect on my sigma 10~20 lens. I know you need the sun at your back for the best results, but it's quite difficult to achieve this. Anyway, I still like the shot....Rgds Willy
nancy   [Jan 21, 2010 at 05:43 PM]
Jan, having read the above comments, I agree with some about the blue patch in the sky...but the hues of blue are quite pleasing and the branches provide a frame for the eye to linger before traveling through the image. The comment I find most intriguing is Andrews about the IR....oh,DO give it a go andlet us see!
wayne d   [Jan 28, 2010 at 11:19 AM]
Jan, positioning your camera lower to the ground would have eliminated most of the featureless middleground and improved the composition. A touch of contast during editing could help too as the general blue tones seem a bit overwhelming. A darker sky could certainly improve things also.
Jan Hagen   [Jan 28, 2010 at 02:47 PM]
Thank you all for valuable input and feedback. I like comment exchanges like these.
Andrew and Nancy - I'll try a IR version of the shot later.
Willy - next time I'll try with/-out pola and/or NDgrad filter.
Wayne - I see your point on a lower angle. I did how ever pull the contrast, but not dareful enough(?). Andrew has a point though, that it tends to be blue in the shadows at this time of day, but a lighter contrast could have done the trick.
Thanks again everyone! Cheers - Jan.
Walkthru   [Feb 09, 2010 at 12:30 AM]
The composition, for me at least, is relatively pleasing Jan - the blue hue throughout the shaded areas doesn't bother me either, though if you wanted, you could alter this with some WB adjustment, then blend back in the sunlit parts of the distant mountains. The dark patch in the sky is almost certainly the polarizer (might be best to ditch it for these types of shot). Cheers, Andrew.

Comment 1 to 12 of 12
Page: 1