Yes, something must change.
This morning, I immediately spotted the new IOTW, but only remembered the Inspiring Image, because Andy announced it.
Maybe we want the impossible? Maybe we could have a monthly Inspiring Image competition? With people nominating images (more than one per person allowed, to make it more interesting) for a month, and then a poll? The winner could then take the place of the IOTW for a week.
Just an idea.