• Welcome to Camera Craniums: The Photography Community for Enthusiasts.

Recent Posts

Members
Stats
  • Total Posts: 62,515
  • Total Topics: 5,735
  • Online today: 17
  • Online ever: 6,071 (March 12, 2026, 03:28:52 AM)
Users Online
  • Users: 0
  • Guests: 12
  • Total: 12
millets
What made you feel good t...Weekly CompetitionsCanon kit to borrow (free...Dreaminess Happy Christmas 2025!NiceVeedi 2-Pack Photogra...DJI Osmo Action 6 Essenti...RØDE Wireless ME Ultra-co...NEEWER Snap On ND Filter ...BRDRC Pocket 3 Camera Bik...Lenovo LOQ | 15.6 inch Fu...DJI Mic 3 (2 TX + 1 RX + ...DJI Mic Mini (2 TX + 1 RX...DJI OSMO Action 5 Pro 4 3...DJI Osmo Action 5 Pro Adv...Post your best shots here

What would make a good Tog Site?

Started by Andrew, March 01, 2014, 01:59:01 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Alfonso_Frisk

That's  why there is an option for critique when you upload your shot.
If you don't want the feedback then just select no.
http://www.fluidr.com/photos/nosmo_king2007
http://www.seateamimages.com/search.php
Wine improves with age, The older I get the more I like it.

StephenBatey

#16
Taking the points in Andrew's post in order (well, the ones I want to comment on!):

By and large, I only use two cameras, a Mamiya RZ67 with the 110mm lens and a 5x4 camera (I currently have two, with a third expected this month) but the models hardly matter; and used with either a 150mm lens or a 210mm lens. Not a great variety.

I'm not convinced by the need to specify at all what was used, or what settings were used, unless it's necessary to be able to judge whether blur is camera shake or subject movement, and the scale of reproduction doesn't make it clear. Even for purposes of technical critique, knowing what the aperture, shutter speed and ISO settings were doesn't help unless you can also post the subject illumination in lux (or foot candles) and the reflectance of the various surfaces in the frame. Unless all this info is available, plus knowing whether the marked shutter speeds and apertures are accurate, you can't comment on the exposure other than more or less was needed - which is obvious from the image apart from any data.

In terms of comments, I normally avoid the technical, because that's not usually where the problems lie. 95% of the time, if you have an auto camera, you can leave it on auto and get a good enough technical result. The times when you can't are generally the times when you're trying to be more creative, and then the technical is in second place. The only rider I'd add is that every "technical" decision is actually an artistic one, even to the extent of giving more or less exposure than a meter objectively interpreted would suggest.

If you want to see a more extended example of one of my critiques (and assuming links to other forums are OK - if not, edit this post and delete this paragraph) see here:

http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/threads/oh-no-not-yet-another-still-life.377753/#post-5745237

Edited to add - oops! I should point out that I'm StephenM on that site ("M" being my middle initial).
On choosing when to critique, I have a simple rule - if I see no merit in the image and (must be both!) no potential in the photographer after looking at other examples, I pass it by. Whether I like or dislike the image is irrelevant, because I can distinguish between what I consider good and bad, and what I like. I can defend much modern art that I wouldn't personally give house room to because I can see that it's good art, just not to my taste. My standard example photographically is that you'll never show me a photo of a happy and healthy cat that I dislike, or a spider that wouldn't fill me with loathing. But I can still identify a bad cat photo when I see one!

On the forum categories, I'm too new here and too unfamiliar with a lot of the site to comment, other than it seems rather a lot.
Art is not what we see; it's what we make others see.

StephenBatey

Quote from: donoreo on March 05, 2014, 02:44:19 PM
I think many people are afraid to post negative comments.  If there is something technically wrong with a photo, the person should know!

One of the problems with giving critique is that how you interpret an image can have a massive bearing on whether you think it's good or bad. I think I've mentioned this before, but on one forum I made two critiques of the same image, posted back to back. I pointed out a number of points the first time, and showed how these were bad from a conventional viewpoint of what made a good image (it was a still life). The second post picked up on exactly the same points, but rather than regarding them as flaws, looked at them as being a deliberate choice on the part of the photographer, and providing the key to the interpretation of the image. First critique - thumbs down, could do better. Second critique - pat on the back, a story well told. I used these posts (plus a similar hatchet job on one of my photos) in my book (with the other photographer's permission) to illustrate how starting point matters.

When you begin from my position that every technical decision is actually an artistic one, you have to consider carefully why something was done that way, rather than concluding that it was done through ignorance. OK, sometime, it will be ignorance - but the mental effort of considering why (even if eventually do conclude that it was a mistake) should open you eyes to other ways of seeing, and other ways of conveying a meaning or a mood.
Art is not what we see; it's what we make others see.

ABERS

#18
The thorny old subject of commenting is always bound to crop up, I would think it's the most discussed subject on any forum that I've visited.

Do you/don't you? Should you/ shouldn't you?

Unless someone asks for it, as far as I'm concerned, the answer is NO. I always take the line that if someone has posted an image on a site they must be satisfied with it. Whether I like it or not should be immaterial, one assumes that they like it otherwise it wouldn't be on view.

Now here's the difficult bit that follows on from that. Should you ever be satisfied with any image you make? I think not. How many times do you revisit your images some time after their production and think "I might have done this or that and it would have a different feel/impact etc."
if that feeling doesn't hit you when you've revisited a few times, then you can allow yourself to be a little bit satisfied. :-\

The rush to post images almost immediately after taking them is one of the reasons why many a potentially impressive image is passed over by viewers. If you have a deadline that is a different matter, if you haven't, surely the world can wait a little longer for your masterpieces. ;)


StephenBatey

Like you, I wouldn't comment unless explicitly asked to. It's usually a problem only when a site doesn't distinguish (by different places to display) whether an image is for critique or admiration. On this site, I wouldn't comment on any image not in the Constructive Critique section.

In the old days, when prints were usually made, it was usually suggested that you hang a print for a week or more, and study it daily before deciding how it should be altered. This also presupposes a small(ish) photographic output; on one site I came across a photographer who regarded 2000-3000 images as normal for a weekend away; and I overheard another photographer at an exhibition saying that they had not bought a Nikon D800 because of the file size, and the time it would take to download 10,000 images. For these photographers, careful consideration after the event would probably mean they had no time to take any more photographs  :)

Art is not what we see; it's what we make others see.

ABERS

I think it was Ansel Adams who said

"Twelve significant photographs in any one year is a good crop."

He failed to mention how many images he took to arrive at the "significant twelve" each year!:) 

StephenBatey

I think I read a news item recently about the Ansel Adams negative archive, which mentioned a large number of never-printed negatives. From memory, the figure was over 10,000. And some negatives were lost in his darkroom fire. Still, 10,000 over a lifetime is still a smaller output than 10,000 over a week...

If practice makes perfect, AA should have been eclipsed years ago  :)

I have a mind to rephrase a remark of Richard Baxter: - "it's not the taking of many images that is necessary to make a man (a) wise and good (photographer) but the well taking of a few, could he be sure to take the best." (For the real quote, substitute "books" for "images" and "reading" for "taking". Or - take aim before you shoot and you might hit the target more often. And I'm using "aim" to suggest purpose as well as pointing.
Art is not what we see; it's what we make others see.

Oldboy

If Ansel Adams, or any of the great photographers from the past, was starting out today would they be seen as giants or also runs?  ???

Simple

Quote from: Oldboy on March 06, 2014, 09:39:41 AM
If Ansel Adams, or any of the great photographers from the past, was starting out today would they be seen as giants or also runs?  ???
I remember from quite a few years ago someone posted a famous picture from a famous photographer on a forum asking for critique and the "helpful" comments were hilarious.
Were they great photographers because they existed in the right time at the right place meeting the right people? Or were they destined to be great photographers because what they did set them apart and they broke new ground? Probably a combination of both? In today's photo rich world they would certainly find it harder to become one of the greats.

StephenBatey

There's a site somewhere that has photos from Henri Cartier-Bresson and others where they are critiqued. I've always had a sneaking suspicion that photographers (at least, as nurtured and trained by camera clubs) have a totally different aesthetic to painters. And a disdain as irrelevant any knowledge of painting - what works, and why; what's been tried, why it worked and why it didn't. An obsession (almost) with equipment and "rules" (I've been picked up before for saying this, but how many people speak of the "guideline" of thirds, rather than the "rule"? I rest my case).

It's almost always the application of rules that gains plaudits and the breaking of them that gets censured. Ever seen a photo posted for critique and the rationale given is "I placed the "X" on a third, and used "Y" as lead in lines..." as if the use of the rules guaranteed success. I have.

So I'd suggest that the "helpful" comments come from a lack of appreciation of what the photographer was trying to achieve (and probably did achieve) simply because those supplying the comments were visually illiterate, and could only slavishly follow rules, without knowing why the "rules" were ever formulated. Rather like using a wide angle lens for landscape photography - there is a use for it to create a particular effect, but the same effect can be created in other ways. But a wide angle lens is a simple technical solution to an artistic problem, and is employed rather than thinking about other ways that are probably better in a given instance.

Why were the greats great? A number were certainly either painters or intimate with painters and the world of art. That enriched their vocabulary and enabled them to say more - to those who could understand. The names I have in  mind also broke new ground, either technically or aesthetically and were appreciated for that - again, by those who could understand, who also probably shaped opinion. There are interesting sidelights coming when you consider some of the "names". One author said of Atget that all the photographic historians were agreed that he was an important figure - but they all disagreed on why. Multi-faceted, perhaps?

The big problem I see today is that world might be photo rich, but it's a matter of being rich in dross. There's a fortune in gold in the world's oceans, but no one who owned a sea would consider themselves rich on that account. The quantity makes it harder to see the quality, and some photo sites (I have flickr specifically in mind) are set up to ensure that what catches the eye is more important than what will last in the mind. Impact is at a premium; long term viewing pleasure isn't. How many books or articles do you see on adding impact to your photos? How many do you see on giving long term viewing pleasure and meaning? If you've seen one, let me know, please.
Art is not what we see; it's what we make others see.

Andrew

Quote from: StephenBatey on March 06, 2014, 11:29:08 AM
How many books or articles do you see on adding impact to your photos? How many do you see on giving long term viewing pleasure and meaning? If you've seen one, let me know, please.

I thought that was what all photography books were about  ;)

So, back on thread - do we put it to a vote, if it is possible, to change the way images are uploaded to only include author and a nice box allowing the photographer to add a nice piece of text explaining the shot - and leaving all the technical stuff out?

This is of course, if Mick is able to change the coding to enact such a change?
1 body, 1 lens, 1 flash gun, 1 tripod, 1 cable release & 1 filter. Keeping it simple!
(I lied, just got a second lens!)

This website is proudly hosted on Crocweb Cloud Website Hosting.


Camera Craniums is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Program. This affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to products on Amazon.