Yesterday (17th) i and a few colleagues from work had a trip to London to enjoy a day of photography.
We looked no different from all the other tourists and people milling around various parts of London with cameras.
And yet we were stopped on 4 (think it was 4) occasions and asked what we were doing and what was so important that we needed to photograph that scene.
1 pair of 'members of public' were even good enough to tell us when we arrived at London Victoria Station and stopped short of telling us where we had been up to that point.
The final person asked us why there was a need to mount cameras on tripods to photograph a scene containing the Sea Containers HO, the Oxo building and part of the London Eye at 8pm!
Whilst i appreciate that they were rehearsing the Official State Opening of Parliament - my question still stands.
What was so special about us? Or is it that our security services have too much time on their hands?
As one of my colleagues said - he would not have suffered such 'constant inquiry in the States!' - the land of paranoia...
"jobs for the boys" comes to mind.. all that security budget to spend ::)
to be asked once would be bad enough..but 4 times.
and to be told what train you came into London on as well...
Told you what train you came in on that sounds very Spook(y)s... was Roz there? :D
Sadly no - but one of my fellow 'togs' was looking about for any cameras...
Hewwo from Soggy Sheffy,
Been ongoing for far too long this anti Photography stuff,thankfuly,the powers that be are now starting to see sense(to a degree)
Theres a piece in this months BFP newsletter about a bloke who was stopped from taking shots on a beach in the UK,the warden was not to be reasoned with,
and he got his way,on investigation the local council had to publish an apology as there IS NO LAW against taking shots in public,
please join the BFP and carry their blue card,
Personaly,ive been hassled in the Peace Gardens in Sheffield,which is DEFFO a public place,but,i cant be bothered anymore,i just walk away,i was prevented on Sheffy railway station by the manager before i,d even got my stuff out, OK,this is a private place,but,this episode contradicted the content of the companies website,,,,,,blah blah,,,,it goes on and on,,,,,
Really,lets be honest about all of this,we are serious threats to the country and its good folk,so,lets bin all our stuff,and be good citizens !!!!!!
Shine Off !!
Quote from: Bigbill on November 18, 2009, 03:23:43 PM
Hewwo from Soggy Sheffy,
so,lets bin all our stuff,and be good citizens !!!!!!
But Bill - if you get rid of all our kit how will we get our weather reports for Sheffield?
It may be worth looking at
http://www.networkrail.co.uk/aspx/777.aspx#photography
Printing off a copy and keep with you if you are intending to photograph on a railway station.
Just printed out the German version of same after a woman had a go at me last week for taking a picture in the Frankfurt underground. Apparently the same rules apply to local transport services here.
And Bill, the Peace Gardens are most certainly a public place. Taken pics there myself and it never occured to me that I was being naughty :P
What always amuses me is that "tourists" are never got at. Apparently "tourists" all have compacts and it's the horrible "professionals" with the big black things in front of their faces that get the aggro.
Hewwo from the Sheffy bit of planet America !!!
Cheers Abers,,,,,
Actualy,thinking about it,,,,maybe all the Canon owners could lead the way ????/
Shine On
Quote from: picsfor on November 18, 2009, 11:29:00 AM
Yesterday (17th) i and a few colleagues from work had a trip to London to enjoy a day of photography.
We looked no different from all the other tourists and people milling around various parts of London with cameras.
And yet we were stopped on 4 (think it was 4) occasions and asked what we were doing and what was so important that we needed to photograph that scene.
1 pair of 'members of public' were even good enough to tell us when we arrived at London Victoria Station and stopped short of telling us where we had been up to that point.
The final person asked us why there was a need to mount cameras on tripods to photograph a scene containing the Sea Containers HO, the Oxo building and part of the London Eye at 8pm!
Whilst i appreciate that they were rehearsing the Official State Opening of Parliament - my question still stands.
What was so special about us? Or is it that our security services have too much time on their hands?
As one of my colleagues said - he would not have suffered such 'constant inquiry in the States!' - the land of paranoia...
Perhaps it was the burkas you were wearing! :legit:
I had fun last night in our Christmas market beer tent. Had been taking photographs of the market at night and walked in to look at the beer tent / band. No professional cameras mate the bouncer says. It`s Ok it`s a D80 it`s not a professional camera says I and carries on walking. "But it takes pictures " he says. Yes , like that guy with the compact over there and the one with the phone over there says I but I`m not taking pictures.". Well it`s a pro camera to me he says. His fellow bouncer says can you put it in your pocket, I do and they let me in! What`s that all about. Inside there was a guy a the front with a D700 and a 70-200 shooting away and another with a canon with a massive lens on it. You have to laugh don`t you :D
. . or emigrate.
Quote from: jinky on November 18, 2009, 06:50:58 PM
I had fun last night in our Christmas market beer tent. Had been taking photographs of the market at night and walked in to look at the beer tent / band. No professional cameras mate the bouncer says. It`s Ok it`s a D80 it`s not a professional camera says I and carries on walking. "But it takes pictures " he says. Yes , like that guy with the compact over there and the one with the phone over there says I but I`m not taking pictures.". Well it`s a pro camera to me he says. His fellow bouncer says can you put it in your pocket, I do and they let me in! What`s that all about. Inside there was a guy a the front with a D700 and a 70-200 shooting away and another with a canon with a massive lens on it. You have to laugh don`t you :D
Interesting point, but as the beer tent is constructed on public land I wonder how they could stop you, unless it was public safety grounds. :doh:
QuoteInside there was a guy a the front with a D700 and a 70-200 shooting away and another with a canon with a massive lens on it.
Maybe they were tourists who had traded in their compact ? :legit:
I think I should invest in an extra large BFP Blue Card. Fortunately they missed :)
Harry
(http://i79.photobucket.com/albums/j153/hssutton/IMG_9294-1.jpg)
Quote from: Tringle WP on November 18, 2009, 06:54:26 PM
. . or emigrate.
Tried that, the grass isnt greener, not as cold and damp though ;) but I do miss morning frosts, oh and bacon sani's :'(
Quote from: hssutton on November 19, 2009, 04:50:34 PM
I think I should invest in an extra large BFP Blue Card. Fortunately they missed :)
Harry
(http://i79.photobucket.com/albums/j153/hssutton/IMG_9294-1.jpg)
ooh, that heli has off camera flash control too :)
Since returning to the U.S. in 2003, I've not been stopped or questioned one time. Granted, it's Pittsburgh -- not New York City. However, even on a trip to NYC in 2005, I was able to walk around a take photos from Upper Manhattan to the financial district without any problems.
I wasn't in the subway system, although I took a few photos outside of one of the stations.
I've been reading a lot about the problems in the U.K. and wonder when this all began. I wonder what would happen if the Queen were in public, taking photos of children.
Quote from: MikeE on November 22, 2009, 03:42:30 PM
I wonder what would happen if the Queen were in public, taking photos of children.
Nothing, even if she shot them with a gun instead of the camera, as the Queen is above the law. ;D
To be fair, I walked all through the financial district of London, back in May, right from Tower bridge through to St Pauls and beyond. No one may any comment or even a second look as far as I could see when I used my 5D - wasn't fitted with a big lens, only my 24-105.
And I was on my own, so might have been construed as guilty!
I wouldn't hesitate to do it again either. Start that game and they have won!
Quote from: Oldboy on November 22, 2009, 05:31:06 PM
Quote from: MikeE on November 22, 2009, 03:42:30 PM
I wonder what would happen if the Queen were in public, taking photos of children.
Nothing, even if she shot them with a gun instead of the camera, as the Queen is above the law. ;D
Technically, she probably is the Law! :D
No, they haven't won, because we're going again.
Though a cynical side of me is tempted to write to the met and ask for a permit or letter of some sort so we can show any one asking!
As I was driving to work today they were talking about this on BBC radio London http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/8384972.stm
seems like a BBC photographer and a couple of friends were prevent taking pic of the London skyline, so you are in exalted company Andrew :D
HI Irv,
funny you add this comment - i was about to add the link in to the Andrew Marr show in which the photographer gives his side of events.
Almost identical to what we suffered...
I saw that AMarr show as well, and was amused by the story. IIRC it was a Community support officer that was the instigator of the encounter, not the WPC, who then backed the CSO.
You can see it here: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/politics/8384972.stm (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/politics/8384972.stm)
H.
wonder if the subject will gain any more prominence now it has appeared in the show...
He looks very shifty to me.
Seriously though - it does make me wonder whether next time i wih to engage on a photography trip to some where i should write to the Chief of Police for that area and ask if they issue an "I'm not a terrorist' permit...
Local news for Sussex, Surrey, Hampshire and Dorset has just done apiece on a guy taking a picture of the Burgess Hill Xmas lights.
Yep - you guessed it, he was stopped by CSO's and asked what he was photographing.
Questioned under the anti terrorism act. Have you seen Burgess Hill Xmas lights?
I'd blow the bloody things up as well!
The Chief Constables supports the actions of his CSO's - you can never be too safe!
Nah, just remain calm , explain what you are doing and wait for him to take some illegal action against you like confiscating equipment, demanding that you format the memory card, or even better unlawful arrest. The compensation will buy you a state of the art studio and every bit of kit you could have imagined.
This story would be very funny if it were not serious: http://www.pressgazette.co.uk/story.asp?storycode=36097
Got it from the PR forum. Plod were so busy telling the photojournalist that he couldn't take pictures that they didn't notice someone leg it with £8000 worth of the chap's kit. Easier to make arrests for non crimes than real ones.
This story made the front page of the independent today.
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/warning-do-not-take-this-picture-1833127.html
Inflation must have hit hard - it was £10k in this version:
http://www.epuk.org/News-snippets/719/police-sued-over-stolen-cameras
I would be tempted in this case to sue the assistant too. I mean what`s the point in having an assistant if they cannot even keep an eye on your gear when you are tied up ;)
Not sure who saw BBC breakfast/news this morning? They featured a(nother) case of a photographer being subjected to a Stop and Account for photographing from the South Bank - the major issue appeared to be the use of a tripod as much as his camera. A police chief (member of ACPO) who was also on agreed that the police could and should have applied common sense in the situation; which does beg the question why the guidance/instruction/policy/command or whatever to use common sense cannot go down the chain to the beat officers - and the PCSO types who seem determined to create issues with photographers based on non-existent law.
Quote from: Nemesis on December 04, 2009, 01:18:33 PM
Not sure who saw BBC breakfast/news this morning? They featured a(nother) case of a photographer being subjected to a Stop and Account for photographing from the South Bank - the major issue appeared to be the use of a tripod as much as his camera. A police chief (member of ACPO) who was also on agreed that the police could and should have applied common sense in the situation; which does beg the question why the guidance/instruction/policy/command or whatever to use common sense cannot go down the chain to the beat officers - and the PCSO types who seem determined to create issues with photographers based on non-existent law.
Yes, saw it before I went out at 06:40 to catch the sunrise. Now it has made the main national news, I wonder if the government will do something about it. :-\
Does it need government intervention? Notwithstanding that we all knew that elements of the ATA were inappropriate to photographers, it is the misinterpretation of law (and the invention of non-existent law) by police officers, PCSOs, council jobsworths and the like that is causing the conflict with photographers.
Quote from: Nemesis on December 04, 2009, 01:49:36 PM
Does it need government intervention? Notwithstanding that we all knew that elements of the ATA were inappropriate to photographers, it is the misinterpretation of law (and the invention of non-existent law) by police officers, PCSOs, council jobsworths and the like that is causing the conflict with photographers.
Possibly, as it would clear up the confusion. :o
The government has outlined areas under section 44 of the act that puts certain areas off-limits to photographers, but hasn't indicated which areas they are in case it's useful to terrorist? As someone else has stated, all you need is a PC/Mac and download Google Street View, which provides a better coverage than a single photo! :doh:
Quote from: Oldboy on December 04, 2009, 01:58:39 PM
Quote from: Nemesis on December 04, 2009, 01:49:36 PM
Does it need government intervention? Notwithstanding that we all knew that elements of the ATA were inappropriate to photographers, it is the misinterpretation of law (and the invention of non-existent law) by police officers, PCSOs, council jobsworths and the like that is causing the conflict with photographers.
Possibly, as it would clear up the confusion. :o
The government has outlined areas under section 44 of the act that puts certain areas off-limits to photographers, but hasn't indicated which areas they are in case it's useful to terrorist? As someone else has stated, all you need is a PC/Mac and download Google Street View, which provides a better coverage that a single photo! :doh:
All railway stations are covered under section 44 but on the whole you don't tend to be pestered unless you're taking pictures of the cctv equipment or using flash. Saying that though I did get asked what I was doing photographing the front of the station at 3am one Monday morning until I explained I was on my break and was just trying some night shots out. He then started showing me some of his pictures he had taken of foreign stations on his phone ::) and wandered off.
Even Steve Bell's having a go now...
(http://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images/Guardian/Pix/pictures/2009/12/07/stevebellif1_071209.jpg) (http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/cartoon/2009/dec/07/steve-bell-anti-terror-laws)