well?
i've really had it with vista and don't have much faith in 7, but is a mac going to be any better?
i've never used a mac and am wondering if it's worth the outlay...damn fancy looking machine thou.
I switched to a mac over 3 years ago now and don't regret it for a moment. I have a vista laptop, which daily has me tearing my hair out, I really wish I'd just bitten the bullet, spent the extra and bought a macbook.
Think it's really down to preference, yes mac's are quite expensive to buy, but they don't have the same "upkeep" costs as windows pc's, that's just my opinion tho. :)
Wouldn't touch Microsoft OS again after working with my iMac.
They are more expensive on the initial outlay but most of your software can be traded in to a Mac version from a Windows version so that should negate most of that cost.
Crashing - mmm, still waiting for this to cause a problem. The force quit application is far more robust than the Windows opposite number (task manager).
Time Machine is the simplest and most efficient back up tool i've ever seen. Wish we'd had it when i was responsible for system back ups.
Screen view - do not know of any thing on Windows that displays as clear or bright as those with a Mac. They really are to droll over.
Copy and paste are also much more efficient on the Mac. It's done through a system wide set up - meaning stuff can be copied from a PDf without the need for a special program (free or otherwise)
Keyboard shortcuts are used much more but once you get the hang of it...
Photoshop and Lightroom behave like they have a turbo charged ram jet driving them after using similar spec computers running Windows.
Come to that- the whole system feels like it runs faster than under MS Windows. Press the on button - no time to make a cup of tea whilst to switches on and then set about logging in.
There are clear differences between the two and you do noeed to learn them to get the most out of the Mac.
But my simple point is this - Snow Leopard brought about a reduction in HD space after installation and upgrading the previous version of Mac OS X.
When have you ever known a Windows upgrade not to increase HD usage by a significant amount?
Hardware and OS are totally under Apple control. MS Windows is under every ones control.
Nope - you can keep our Windows - i'll stick to my new MAc OS X thank you. Bigger brighter screen, faster and less bugs. I'm not a games player so i don't miss any of it.
Oh yes- one last thing - it doesn't come with Internet Explorer!
Go into your local Apple dealer and hav a play. But remember to take your cheque book cos you won't want to leave without one!
If you go for the desktop, have the space and can afford it get the new 27 inc iMac, failing that get the 24 inch version.
I have the 24 inch version with 3.06ghz duo intel processor with 1Tb HD and 4gb RAM. It comes with a 512mb graphics chipset as well and an all in one optical drive (not blu ray though).
If you get it from an Apple store they will give you some free training as well i think.
Quote from: picsfor on October 25, 2009, 04:47:04 PM
Wouldn't touch Microsoft OS again after working with my iMac.
They are more expensive on the initial outlay but most of your software can be traded in to a Mac version from a Windows version so that should negate most of that cost.
Crashing - mmm, still waiting for this to cause a problem. The force quit application is far more robust than the Windows opposite number (task manager).
Time Machine is the simplest and most efficient back up tool i've ever seen. Wish we'd had it when i was responsible for system back ups.
Screen view - do not know of any thing on Windows that displays as clear or bright as those with a Mac. They really are to droll over.
Copy and paste are also much more efficient on the Mac. It's done through a system wide set up - meaning stuff can be copied from a PDf without the need for a special program (free or otherwise)
Keyboard shortcuts are used much more but once you get the hang of it...
Photoshop and Lightroom behave like they have a turbo charged ram jet driving them after using similar spec computers running Windows.
Come to that- the whole system feels like it runs faster than under MS Windows. Press the on button - no time to make a cup of tea whilst to switches on and then set about logging in.
There are clear differences between the two and you do noeed to learn them to get the most out of the Mac.
But my simple point is this - Snow Leopard brought about a reduction in HD space after installation and upgrading the previous version of Mac OS X.
When have you ever known a Windows upgrade not to increase HD usage by a significant amount?
Hardware and OS are totally under Apple control. MS Windows is under every ones control.
Nope - you can keep our Windows - i'll stick to my new MAc OS X thank you. Bigger brighter screen, faster and less bugs. I'm not a games player so i don't miss any of it.
Oh yes- one last thing - it doesn't come with Internet Explorer!
Go into your local Apple dealer and hav a play. But remember to take your cheque book cos you won't want to leave without one!
If you go for the desktop, have the space and can afford it get the new 27 inc iMac, failing that get the 24 inch version.
I have the 24 inch version with 3.06ghz duo intel processor with 1Tb HD and 4gb RAM. It comes with a 512mb graphics chipset as well and an all in one optical drive (not blu ray though).
If you get it from an Apple store they will give you some free training as well i think.
Amen to that :tup:
I'm quite happy with Windows regardless of flavour. ;D
yes but he already has over 100 wins in the arcade and as the site gains increased membership so it gains increased competition for those top spots.
Windows in any flavour is not going to help - he needs something bigger and faster :2funny:
been looking in the Apple shop at the Trafford center (Manchester), i'm sure if i had had my daughter with me (12% student discount) we would have bought the 27" imac on the spot :o
I was told to lay off buying aperature straight away as the software that is bundled is good enought to start...will my cs3 extended work on it?
1 year's "training" is £79 and they will put everything from my pc onto the mac
my only concern is if i write a document useing apples ibook will window users be able to open it?
CS3 works no probs - as i say you can contact Adobe and they will do a media swap.
A form to fill out and a £5 fee for media delivery costs but otherwise no probs.That's what i done with CS4.
Software that is bundled? Must mean iPhoto. It's a nice program for free and is what Microsoft would love to give with Windows - but they don't have anything that good.
It's a bit like Bridge but free! As i have Lightroom i don't use it.
Basically iPhoto would be your image management software and you can configure it to use CS3 as your editor. It has a few basic tools but no where near CS3 level - unless you're happy to use Bridge.
Step Daught uses iPhoto and she manages all her images (pictures and art work alike) with it and loves it.
So far as writing documents is concerned, because we needed MS Office compatibility we bought the MS Office for Mac - student/ home edition £70 or their abouts.
It is different in its appearance and it can require a bit of learning but it has some nice touches and once you get used to it... Entourage is the equivalent to Outlook but otherwise the rest are the same.
No VB script on Macs so all those nasty little things that make Windows stuff go wrong don't make to a Mac.
The other difference is getting used to have an A3 sheet in full size on the screen... Something else!
Take the daught and get the discount, let them sort it all out for you and get some training. See if they'll throw a book in as well for good measure. Oh yes - speakers are great for listening to music with as well whilst working!
Go Mac if you want, but the next time you are desperate to throw some money away, please click the 'send money to Tringle WP' link located next to this post. I'll buy at least two equivalent PCs for the same money, and even send one back to you so you don't feel you've lost out :D
I'll even turn the brightness and contrast on the display right up so you'll feel at home :legit:
i may buy one just to look at, one thing (one more thing), what about a tv card, if i want to hook up an aerial, can i do so?
Have to admit you've got me there. Never though to look or enquire.
Plays film DVD well enough. Web stuff plays well enough.
You'd have to ask the Apple guys on that one i'm afraid. It has every thing else - i can not believe it can't watch TV!
i was shown a hd trailer...FANTASTIC! it should be really good for photo editing.
rest assured - it seems like the Mac was custom built to process and edit photos.
If you decide to go for the Mac and opt for the 1Tb hard drive - you will need an external drive for back up purposes of the same or larger capacity.
Make sure you get one with a fire wire 800 connector. Speed of data transfer is literally live.
I've said it before and all say it again, if this were an e-mail i was typing - the data would be backed up to the EHD simultaneously exactly as i'm typing it.
And the restore function is excellent as well.
sounds good :tup:
the target on Archery will be as big as a dart board ;D
Before ditching what's possibly a perfectly useable and functional computer (afaik, Apple and PC components aren't compatible with each other), give another operating system a try first.
Remember, there's more operating systems out there than just the several (or one, as microsoft want you to know) windows-based ones... some of them are actually legally free to download, use, copy, etc!
linux is the only other one i can think of, but that takes some getting used too, or so i'm told.
Linux is an extremely established OS nowadays and once mastered is every bit as good as Windows.
But you do need that 'hacker' mind set to get the most from it.
I don't have that mind set any more - i just want switch on and go.
If i wanted my computing to be exciting i'd get an under specced computer and dump Vista on it!
I got so fed up with my Vista laptop that I seriously considered lashing out on a Mac. Got a bigger laptop [you would'nt want to carry it all day!] with more power running XP and now, touch wood, don't have problems as it just seems to work. I just ignore the Microsoft stuff like IE and hotmail.
Re watching TV on your Mac.....
Never done it (Sky+ and iPlayer do everything I need) but Elgato specialise in this area and have done for ages. Their EyeTV hybrid looks cool and the EyeTV Sat could be very nice indeed. The eyeTV DTT even works under Windows 7. As well as OS X.
Re writing docs that PCs can read. The short answer is "yes". The long answer is "pretty much". I use Office 2004 for heavy lifting and Pages for pretty stuff. Occasionally I send Word docs to people on PCs and they have always opened them no problem (or no more than you would expect from a 5 year old Office suite). There are some features that aren't supported (VB and some complex Spreadsheet stuff) but not stuff I've ever used.
I'm really getting to like Pages '09 though (they now support proper mail merge which is one thing I rely on Word for). I just exported a doc from Pages '09 in Word format and opened it in Word. No problem at all. There were 2 warnings on export (one of those was "you exported it as a word processing document"). I also tried RTF and it was OK but some stuff got moved around (the document relied heavily on text boxes and RTF doesn't really support these). All text, fonts and font formatting were fine.
I have Aperture and it's fine. I don't use it because I prefer Lightroom. Every time I open iPhoto to do something boring I'm amazed to find it has some new feature I didn't know about. It's really pretty cool.
BTW don't shell out for those posey speakers in the Apple store (well, you can if you want). Mine's plugged into a Cambridge Audio amp and some MS10s. Cost me less than £200 at Richer Sounds and sound better than most computers I've heard. Apart from the one in the gallery with its 6 speakers system........
As for Macs costing more......maybe. But I've never owned a laptop as long as I've had my MacBook and it's still very very nice. That includes the Alienware lappie which was the last PC I bought. Some reports say TCO is lower on Macs. Like I care.
I have a Mac Lappy and a desktop PC. Both are good, both have their own vageries. I'm more used to PC's so I do occassionally get frustrated with my Mac.
However, the next desktop I get may well be a MAC. It seems to need less raw power than a PC to do the same thing (My dual core Laptop seems as quick as my quad core PC)
And Mac's Timemachine is brilliant!
A quick couple of thought re your questions relating to the mac:
1. The TV tuner - http://www.elgato.com/elgato/int.html (http://www.elgato.com/elgato/int.html) is the way to go - it will turn your mac into a PVR like a Sky+. You can also save recorded TV to play on other devices such as the iPhone et al...
2. If you get iWork rather than MS Office, will other people be able to open docs et al in MS Office - yes. You have the option to save a an MS Word doc as well as apple pages files as well as other things. If you want to save something (such as a legal doc) and do not want someone to edit it, you can even save from any application your file as a .pdf. I got MS Office and to be honest Word kept crashing and causing me issues - so I got iWork. It does all I want it to do both professionally and for personal use. If I'm sending work to colleagues I save a word doc or .pdfs.
3. I'm not a prolific software enhancer. I have both iPhoto (free), Aperture and Photoshop CS2. I have a website which is hidden behind a user name and password as it houses various videos, photos et al of my son (it allows those family members living abroad the chance to see him grow). For those photos I just use iPhoto - the facial recognition is fantastic! For my own photos - which I take a bit more time over, I use Aperture (both can be used to upload easily - I just like to keep things a bit separate). It is a very powerful bit of software and as you can now get plugins - I hardly use photoshop anymore.
I agree with other suggestions that if your computer is usable and its just the OS, have a try of another OS - if you are really sure you want a Mac - have you considered a Hackintosh? Have a look at episode 97 of Tekzilla http://revision3.com/tekzilla/satadock (http://revision3.com/tekzilla/satadock) for a legitimate way of putting OS X on a computer that is not a mac.
Quote from: picsfor on October 26, 2009, 12:17:00 AM
Linux is an extremely established OS nowadays and once mastered is every bit as good as Windows.
But you do need that 'hacker' mind set to get the most from it.
I don't have that mind set any more - i just want switch on and go.
I used to have that mind set when I was learning how Linux behaved. Back in those days (is it really "back in those days"??), my desktop was WindowMaker... that really did need working on to get it going. The distro was Mandrake, which did a lot of things 'out of the box', most of which covered what I wanted anyway. In that distro, I learned how to compile source, why deleting stuff whilst logged in as root isn't a good idea, and how to turn Vim in to a very powerful version of notepad.exe.
Now, I have neither the time nor inclination to whip myself with a birch branch, so I'm using Ubuntu. It's handling (thinks...) everything I throw at it. So now, all I do is switch-on and go.
... or plug-in and go...? ;)
The new release of Ubuntu is out on 29th. It boots in less than 30 seconds on anything. I shall be downloading it for certain.
I think picsfor said it was a good as windows - well it's not; it's much faster and almost unbreakable.
Ubuntu does everything you want right out of the box. Installing new applications is as simple as searching in Synaptic and pressing 'install'. Fingers crossed the only gap in the linux armoury is plugged and I can calibrate my monitor. But if not I'll do that in a windows VM and copy the data to linux.
And best of all Bibble will run on linux (as well as windows and Mac).
So what we're saying is 'Linux has come of age?'
Quote from: picsfor on October 26, 2009, 03:14:34 PM
So what we're saying is 'Linux has come of age?'
Well, it's the underlying OS in MacOS, isn't it?
It will really have come of age when the average IT idiot can use it and install it. Which is pretty much the state with MacOS.
H.
well after careful consideration i am now the owner of an imac :tup:
screen size will take a bit of getting used to and i can't believe i have to load all my cd's onto itunes again, i don't know what to put in my unit as i don't have a tower..maybe some dried flowers.
Save yourself some time, in iTunes on the PC, back up your collection to DVDs, then on the mac, restore your collection.
i will do just that, cheers
congratulations on the purchase of your Mac.
Yes, screen size does take a bit of getting used to, as does the clarity by which it shows your pictures.
If you have an external HD couldn't you back up all your music to that?
As my previous hard drives weren't big enough to hold much music i never had much to transfer across - but i am no loading my CD collection on to the Mac.
Time Machine does such a great job of backing up that i do not have any other back up strategy in place other than physically reloading all the CD's.
At least you know where to come with questions on how to if you're not sure.
I hope your purchase proves to be as fruitful as mine has been. And now the wife chats with her daughter in America via video link in iChat it's starting to save a bit of money on the phone bill as well!
Quote from: happypaddler on October 26, 2009, 11:27:33 PM
Save yourself some time, in iTunes on the PC, back up your collection to DVDs, then on the mac, restore your collection.
Alternatively, move your iTunes library to an external HDD and then load it directly from it. For the last year and a bit we've had our iTunes library on a NAS and share it around the house. see: http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1751 (http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1751)
Quote from: hevans on October 27, 2009, 06:26:50 AM
Quote from: happypaddler on October 26, 2009, 11:27:33 PM
Save yourself some time, in iTunes on the PC, back up your collection to DVDs, then on the mac, restore your collection.
Alternatively, move your iTunes library to an external HDD and then load it directly from it. For the last year and a bit we've had our iTunes library on a NAS and share it around the house. see: http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1751 (http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1751)
Or if you actually want them on the Mac (and putting them on a NAS is the best - my Sonos can see all my music :) ) then just wire the two puters together (Cat 5 would probably do it, firewire if you have to) and drag the music from the PC to the Mac. Drag it right onto iTunes and let the glory of OS X do the rest ;)
It's a Mac. It's easier than you think. [TM]
Another way is to make sure both have the latest version of iTunes - then hit the sharing icon, and tell it to sync the libraries so that both have the same music collection. I've put our collection on a wireless EHD and using this both the iMac and MacBook as well as the wifes rubbish work HP thing can stream music through iTunes, without the collection actually having to have copies of the music. I do have it syncing onto my macbook so I have music when out and about, using the syncing set up if ever I put a new album into a collection, the other gets a copy as soon as they are both on the home wifi, without me having to do anything.
There are so many ways.....
I've been back and forth now, contemplating on what to choose.
I'm now considering a Mac computer as well, and been drooling over the latest 27" iMac I saw on the web yesterday.
Happy with your buy - alan1572?
picsfor:
- In order to run my pc software - CS3 and Elements 8.0 - is it enough to buy Parallels Desktop 4, to be able to use these programs?
- With iPhoto installed already on the iMac, and the above mentioned programs operating, would I really need Aperture2?
Cheesr Jan
Jan, i got the 27" imac and i love it, still (and will be for a while) getting used to it, i'm glad i took the plunge and now need to start using it.
Quote from: Jan Hagen on October 29, 2009, 11:11:01 AM
picsfor:
- In order to run my pc software - CS3 and Elements 8.0 - is it enough to buy Parallels Desktop 4, to be able to use these programs?
- With iPhoto installed already on the iMac, and the above mentioned programs operating, would I really need Aperture2?
Cheesr Jan
Sorry to jump in... I know you directed your question to picsfor - sorry to him as well. If your going for a Mac yes you can use parallels - but there is no need as you get Boot Camp built in to OS X which will let you install Windows on you mac (look at this podcast for how to do it - click on the Windows on a Mac on the left http://cnettv.cnet.com/?tag=hdr;brandnav (http://cnettv.cnet.com/?tag=hdr;brandnav)). But in all honesty (this is not said with malice) - and this may put the cat amongst the pigeons - if your changing to mac, change to mac - don't change your hardware which has an OS which works perfectly with it, to then use an emulator to run a different OS. The better way is to contact Adobe and ask them to swap your install disks to the Mac from the PC - from memory this costs about £10 and you send off your PC versions and get the Mac versions instead (be warned though that the current mac version of elements is not as high as the PC version). There are many reasons for this: virus' are more prevalent on windows machines (they are coming to the mac as mac's become more popular), you will not have the full functionality of your mac OS X and other good free/built in software if all your photos are on a windows partition, that windows partition will soon clog up with updated (on an install of Snow Leopard I got back space on both my mac hard drives)...
As to your other question, iPhoto is great as an alternative to Bridge. Aperture is more like an alternative to Lightroom. I have Aperture and I think its better than Lightroom (I tried the 1st trial version of Lightroom and it has improved since then). If you have your other adobe softwares transferred to the mac OS, I doubt you will need Aperture - but you could always download the trial version and have a play.
If that sounded like a rant it was not meant to be one - so sorry if it comes across as one.
What HP said. If you go Mac, go Mac.
FWIW I use VMWare for a very exotic app that my lab uses and Crossover as a lightweight way to run IE (Abbey Business bank hardly works on anything else plus I can test websites in IE). I much prefer these to Bootcamp as I don't need to reboot to swap OS - I can have a bunch of windows on the desktop - some are OS X and some are Windoze. If I was bored one day I'd probably install Linux to see what the fuss is about.
Quotethey are coming to the mac as mac's become more popular
Don't get me started on that argument. $25K* and immortal fame as the person to write the first viable virus** for OS X ain't enough for you? 2.8 million machines*** (most of them not running any virus protection) not enough to infect? OS X is intrinsically more resistant to virus writers. Or maybe Mac users are just smarter. It's not immune but it's holding up pretty well.
* they had to pull the competition because the US federal law forbids people from encouraging you to write viruses.....
** in 2005 Symantec (a company that makes money from other people writing viruses and from the fear of malware) said that the number of OS X viruses would rocket now that Macs were more popular. Sophos (another company that make money from spreading alarm) report a total of 11 viruses, malware and Trojans in the 4 years since then - most if not all requiring user action to trigger. There were, for example, according to a market leading analyst with a vested interest in scaring you, none in 2005.
*** projected sales of Snow Leopard for first quarter. There are of course plenty more Macs in the world running Older OSs (I have 3). And I suppose some people may pirate Snow Leopard rather than buy it. 2.8M is at the ultra conservative end of potential hosts.
totally agree with Happypaddler and Jonathan.
If you're going to go for a Mac - then do so properly. Swap you Adobe stuff to the Mac version. To do this you download a form which involves listing all your adobe software with licence numbers etc.
You send this off which, when approved, results in you getting a letter of destruction you sign and send back. On signing it you have to remove all copies of the software from your windows computers and destroy the media (that's what you've signed for in the letter). Once Adobe get that letter you get an e-mail asking you to call a number and cough up some dosh for postage of new media etc. Mine for CS4 was £5.60 if memory serves. A week later- and hey presto new disks come through the door. And boy did i notice a difference in speed at which the software worked.
It is a bit of a nuisance not having software for a week or two but then if you've just got a Mac for the first time you'll be busy learning it so when the software arrives you're already to go. I have a Windows laptop i keep for the odd thing that needs windows (usually helping people with their windows problems...). Horrible thing now. I detest even switching it on.
As for Aperture 2 - why do you want it? Bridge and iPhoto would do an excellent job of managing your library. Best way has been said is to download the trial version of Aperture and Lightroom and see if they offer anything worth spending that much money for.
"Hei folkens"
Thanks a lot for your feedback and time spent guys, very much appreciated.
You've enlightened me on the missing link, when purchasing an iMac, with regards to swapping the Adobe software to a Mac version. The puzzle is soon finished, I think, with your latest info. It all makes sense now and total costs will go down. I basically need an iMac and a external hard drive for back ups. That's what you're all saying?
Unfortunately the Apple store in Bergen, didn't manage to enlighten me in the same way. I guess they want to sell. I'll ask them about the issue of swapping to Mac versions and see what kind of recommendation they come up with, or I'll just ask you guys for the necessary link.
Again - Thanks a lot guys - and have a great weekend, while I'm working.
Cheers Jan
with regards to swapping software from windows to mac you go to the Adobe web site and log in (or register if you haven't registered your software)
you can then search the knowledge base for software platform swap.
You can also e-mail customer support whom ay help you bypass some of the process.
The Apple shop will not be able to help you with a platform swap for your software.
I no longer have the e-mail addresses for when i done it (8 months ago), sorry
Quote from: Jonathan on October 29, 2009, 04:24:00 PM
Quotethey are coming to the mac as mac's become more popular
Don't get me started on that argument. $25K and immortal fame as the person to write the first viable virus for OS X ain't enough for you? 2.8 million machines (most of them not running any virus protection) not enough to infect? OS X is intrinsically more resistant to virus writers. Or maybe Mac users are just smarter. It's not immune but it's holding up pretty well.
Everyone's convinced that Windows operating systems get more viruses due to the OS being widely used. As you say though, it's not simply due to Windows being on more computers, it's simply due to Windows being inherently more insecure. It's true that Windows security has improved slightly since the old Win98 days, but not by much. Users who reinstall their beloved Microsoft OS don't seem to be concerned with user permissions. What other OS, by default, drops any old user into an admininstrator mode, with full access to anywhere? Linux users are given the option of adding more than one user to an install, as well as defining a root password... Linux users aren't dumped immediately into a "Access all areas" GUI.
... and if you start to maul with user permissions in a Windows-based OS, well... I've had headaches from various applications (some from Microsoft themselves!) which don't understand that the user is not necessarily the administrator.
As for the old "Infections will increase as $OS becomes more popular" comment, it's only the *risk* of infection which will increase as $OS becomes more popular.
Viruses for Linux? True to the nature of Linux, there's some virus sourcecode available on the internet, and it's free to download. Yep, anyone can have a play with that. And yep, the Linux OS is a pretty hostile environment to viruses, just as it should be. :)
Quote from: Hybridphotog on October 30, 2009, 04:09:07 PM
Viruses for Linux? True to the nature of Linux, there's some virus sourcecode available on the internet, and it's free to download. Yep, anyone can have a play with that.
You mean open source allows you to acquire and develop your own virus and infect your own computer without Microsoft making money on it?
What ever next? ;D ;D ;D ;D
Quote from: Hybridphotog on October 30, 2009, 04:09:07 PM
Everyone's convinced that Windows operating systems get more viruses due to the OS being widely used. As you say though, it's not simply due to Windows being on more computers, it's simply due to Windows being inherently more insecure. It's true that Windows security has improved slightly since the old Win98 days, but not by much. Users who reinstall their beloved Microsoft OS don't seem to be concerned with user permissions. What other OS, by default, drops any old user into an admininstrator mode, with full access to anywhere? Linux users are given the option of adding more than one user to an install, as well as defining a root password... Linux users aren't dumped immediately into a "Access all areas" GUI.
... and if you start to maul with user permissions in a Windows-based OS, well... I've had headaches from various applications (some from Microsoft themselves!) which don't understand that the user is not necessarily the administrator.
And here is the crux of the issue: it's not the OS, it's
how it's been configured and used. This bleating about viruses etc. has made me curious enough to hunt through the virus scan log files and firewall log files on the home PC and laptop. The home PC is well protected behind several firewalls, virus scanner on the machine and virus scanner on the Inet service provider. The laptop travels around a bit and is often connected to numerous dodgy wireless networks.
In these log files, there hasn't been a single virus detected; and by this I mean not an infection, but just the detection of the virus in a file that's made it to the computer or attempted to be downloaded. So, obviously I haven't been frequenting the right web sites. From this, I do wonder why I bother running a virus scanner, but then I'm reminded about the risk of not having your child immunised against measles.
There have been many port scans on the laptop, none on the home PC, the joys of running a good firewall.
Quote from: Hybridphotog on October 30, 2009, 04:09:07 PM
As for the old "Infections will increase as $OS becomes more popular" comment, it's only the *risk* of infection which will increase as $OS becomes more popular.
The risk of a machine becoming infected will probably stay the same. The occurrence of infections will increase if a new weakness is found and exploited - it's a simple product: #machines * probability of infection.
However, the risk can be increased due to the increased attention paid by virus writers to the target machine as more manpower is used to investigate the system for weaknesses (we assume that the various operating systems remain unchanged, odds are they will also be made more secure over time). In this sense, obscurity is a form of defence, but a pretty poor form of defence.
The real threat for a well configured operating systems comes not from the OS, but from the third party applications that are installed on them (flash players, media streaming players, web browsers, etc.) There's nothing to stop a virus writer exploiting a weakness in (for example) the Mac version of Firefox/Opera/etc. You click on a web page, and the Mac/Windows/Linux machine is compromised and runs the payload with whatever privileges the user has. Again, not a failing of the OS, but the third party application's security/implementation - the amount of damage is only limited by the privileges given to the account.
I think the real threat to the Mac/Linux community is that as the machines become more popular, the number of user instigated threats will increase (download and running suspect applications) as there will be more malicious payloads written and waiting to be discovered. From my experiences, this is the main threat for a Windows machine that's well configured. The advantage of the windows community right now is that they are more sensitised to the problem, and the anti-virus groups are busy making sure that such malicious payloads are detected and the news of their malignancy is spread quickly.
Quote from: Hybridphotog on October 30, 2009, 04:09:07 PM
Viruses for Linux? True to the nature of Linux, there's some virus sourcecode available on the internet, and it's free to download. Yep, anyone can have a play with that. And yep, the Linux OS is a pretty hostile environment to viruses, just as it should be. :)
But the Linux OS won't protect you from a malicious payload that you download inadvertently thinking it's an MP3. But it happens to leverage the weakness in a third party MP3-player that then trashes your user account, or worse sets up its own web server as a cron job to start a web server that then serves up the payload to others. The average user wouldn't know where to look for the crontab entries, so it'll be left to run in peace, and undiscovered.
It's not the OS, it's how it's configured and used.
Why are there more threats to windows machines? Because there are a lot of very old machines out there that were installed with an OS at a time when security was not such an issue. If you believe MSoft isn't making sure the latest versions of their OS is configured for security by default, then you're being quite naïve.
As an aside: I regularly use Linux, Windows and Macs. They are all a tool, each with their own strengths and weaknesses - pick the one with the user interface you like and the application support you need and leave the religious zealotry to the Middle East, or at least the age old question "Nikon or Canon?".
H.
Interesting you say that H. I have had a computer since about 1990 - and can only remember getting a virus once in all that time - a couple of times since then the virus software trapped a few, but I can't remember the last time that happened.
Funnily enogh only this week, my wife phoned me to tell me that something wierd had happened and the computer had a pop up (Very windows standard style) to say it had detected some viri and download this program to sort it all out. Not being daft, she did nothing!
Basically it looks like the site she clicked on (Nothing dodgy, something she looks at occasionally and has done since) was either spammed or had a hook to load a different page with then asked you to download a program, which I guess was a virus.
My MAC doesn't have any AV software on it - and won't until real threats actually start to appear!
Quote from: anglefire on October 31, 2009, 05:31:46 AM
Interesting you say that H. I have had a computer since about 1990 - and can only remember getting a virus once in all that time - a couple of times since then the virus software trapped a few, but I can't remember the last time that happened.
I remember an incident at work where a virus took down nearly every machine because the IT department hadn't patched the machines with an update that was about a year old. My laptop (self administered) wasn't affected because it had a firewall and had been patched. This was ~7 years ago now, and times, attitudes and priorities have changed. The real culprit: the "it can't happen here" mentality.
QuoteFunnily enogh only this week, my wife phoned me to tell me that something wierd had happened and the computer had a pop up (Very windows standard style) to say it had detected some viri and download this program to sort it all out. Not being daft, she did nothing!
Basically it looks like the site she clicked on (Nothing dodgy, something she looks at occasionally and has done since) was either spammed or had a hook to load a different page with then asked you to download a program, which I guess was a virus.
This is exactly the situation I described. And if the payload had been designed to work on a mac and had been clicked on? Would the result have been much different from the same scenario with a PC?
QuoteMy MAC doesn't have any AV software on it - and won't until real threats actually start to appear!
Hmmm. I'm reminded of the Indians of North America on arrival of small pox from the virus protected Europeans. ;)
Although, perhaps the better analogy is the difference between the Spanish flu in the early 1900s, where no vaccines existed, nor real measures to counter them, is like the 1990s -> 2004 on the PC, and the current swine flu is more like today with the PC (rates of infection/catastrophe are quite low and a vaccine is on the way and more important plans to handle an outbreak are ready). The Macs are finally developing a sizeable market share in an environment where people are sensitized to the threat (although there are still enough idiots out there), so their period of relative safety in obscurity took them through the Spanish flu period where security wasn't the highest priority.
H.
I don't get viruses but bugs are a different matter! :2funny: :2funny: :2funny:
I've now officially defected to Mac and the new "baby" was set up yesterday. Thrilled and excited I could unpack the long awaited Christmas gift, to myself. Hopefully screen flicker problems are sorted out and won't appear on my screen. What a beauty! A huge lovely screen, crystal clear and plenty of new stuff to get used to. Elements 8.0 installed, uploaded a couple of pictures and my eyes went all watery. Some time will have to pass, several evenings that is, before I get the hang of it. To my wife's disagreement I guess!? But it'll be a wonderful time indeed and I'm looking forward to it.
Thanks a lot to happy paddler, picsfor, jonathan and alan1572, for valuable input earlier!
I owe you a pint or two!
Cheers :beer:
Jan
i am certain you will not look back, apart from the function, it's a thing a beauty.
I am sorry to say that for photography - i could not see any other way of working.
Even the every day tasks such as e-mail and internet i find much simpler to get on with.
What i still find unnerving and yet blissful at the same time is the need (by and large) to not have some virus checker interrogate every mouse click, keyboard click, internet site access or file import for some virus, trojan etc.
As for the crystal clarity of that screen, it really is something else.
I'm glad your Christmas present was worth the wait. This will of course mean we will not hear from you for a bit while you import all your pictures and discover some of the 'duffers' were actually rather good.
Quote from: picsfor on January 20, 2010, 09:52:21 AM
I am sorry to say that for photography - i could not see any other way of working.
What i still find unnerving and yet blissful at the same time is the need (by and large) to not have some virus checker interrogate every mouse click, keyboard click, internet site access or file import for some virus, trojan etc.
Not to spoil Jan's fun, but you know you could have gotten this for free by installing Linux. It's even more immune than Mac. That said, I, unlike Dave from Clacton, can not get the hang of GIMP so I'm still using Windoze for my main PC.
I had to use Ubuntu yesterday for a print job. It's just bliss. But it still won't calibrate the screen. Here's hoping for version 10.
Quote from: Tringle WP on January 20, 2010, 02:29:15 PM
I had to use Ubuntu yesterday for a print job. It's just bliss. But it still won't calibrate the screen. Here's hoping for version 10.
From what I understand, you can calibrate the screen using a windows boot, then copy the calibration file to the Linux installation for use. Still it'd be easier if it could just be done within Linux.
H.
Indeed Hugh, that you can. Bit of a pain though, and there are still problems with running a decent editor (pax GIMP) under Virtual Box. The day will come, I hope :)
Glad you made the jump. I am glad I did for music production. I compose and mix mix music on a Mac, but for my photos.. (for the time being atleast...) I use a windows based laptop.
I have a 20" screen and it is stunning... Was a bit scary at first, using a new OS.. But as long as you remember not to just close the window when exiting a program, you will be fine.. also remember to do disk permissions repairs regularly in Applications --->Disk Utility... All should run smoothly..
Quote from: Simon on January 21, 2010, 08:11:51 PM
Glad you made the jump. I am glad I did for music production. I compose and mix mix music on a Mac, but for my photos.. (for the time being atleast...) I use a windows based laptop.
I have a 20" screen and it is stunning... Was a bit scary at first, using a new OS.. But as long as you remember not to just close the window when exiting a program, you will be fine.. also remember to do disk permissions repairs regularly in Applications --->Disk Utility... All should run smoothly..
what do you mean?
it's a bit like defragging your disk on windows in that you should do every so often to ensure the better running of your mac.
It is a really simple thing to do - just follwo the above instructions - any question and you know where to come...
Quote from: picsfor on January 21, 2010, 09:59:19 PM
it's a bit like defragging your disk on windows in that you should do every so often to ensure the better running of your mac.
It is a really simple thing to do - just follwo the above instructions - any question and you know where to come...
are we both talking about the close the window thing and not the permission thing?
Quote from: Tringle WP on January 20, 2010, 02:29:15 PM
I had to use Ubuntu yesterday for a print job. It's just bliss. But it still won't calibrate the screen. Here's hoping for version 10.
Oh right, I'd forgotten that bit. There is a way to do it, as I did, but can't for the life of me remember how. :-[
Quote from: spinner on January 21, 2010, 11:46:39 PM
Quote from: Tringle WP on January 20, 2010, 02:29:15 PM
I had to use Ubuntu yesterday for a print job. It's just bliss. But it still won't calibrate the screen. Here's hoping for version 10.
Oh right, I'd forgotten that bit. There is a way to do it, as I did, but can't for the life of me remember how. :-[
It's here: http://www.ubuntufieldmanual.com/?q=node/38
I'll have a go when I've got some time. Then I just have to get Virtual Box going properly.
Quote from: alan1572 on January 21, 2010, 11:22:51 PM
Quote from: picsfor on January 21, 2010, 09:59:19 PM
it's a bit like defragging your disk on windows in that you should do every so often to ensure the better running of your mac.
It is a really simple thing to do - just follwo the above instructions - any question and you know where to come...
are we both talking about the close the window thing and not the permission thing?
i was talking about the permission thing...