Go on, what's your theory?
I'll be disappointed if it's a conjuring trick though I suspect it must be (writing on the balls after the draw or whatever). I rather hoped he just tricked me into believing he'd predicted it when he hadn't (if he wrote down a different set of numbers and convinced me I had just seen them drawn) but the papers don't seem to back this one up.
One thing's for sure. He didn't predict them - so how did he do it?
Haven't got a clue. Just have to watch on Friday.
Nick
Didn't see it. But as he didn't announce the numbers before they were drawn, it would be a conjuring trick.
Most elegant method would be to have a time machine.
H.
Who's Derren Brown?
Quote from: picsfor on September 10, 2009, 09:08:16 AM
Who's Derren Brown?
When you have 49 minutes, go watch The Heist (about half way down here (http://www.channel4.com/programmes/derren-brown/4od#2918279)).
It's EITHER a cheap and pointless hoax by the guy who damaged his brand with the Russian Roulette thing OR the most amazing piece of mind control ever shown on television. You decide. Because short of believing or not there's really no way to tell.
I did not see it - but if you could predict the lottery would you brag about it or would you win it - I know where I stand.
Anyone remember Horace Batchelor on Radio Luxembourg??
Quote from: greypoint on September 10, 2009, 11:23:07 AM
Anyone remember Horace Batchelor on Radio Luxembourg??
Yes! :-[
Gordon Brown's new chancellor maybe?
He lived in K E Y N S H A M. I seem to remember :2funny:
Quote from: CannOffice on September 10, 2009, 10:31:42 AM
I did not see it - but if you could predict the lottery would you brag about it or would you win it - I know where I stand.
Good point, but do it every year with the euro lottery or the main ones.
Did anyone claim that £146m last week or the other week?
i am going to guess that his balls are wireless digital displays that someone has keyed in as the draw took place :)
I actually quite like Derren Brown.
I suspect that although he will reveal all on Friday, I also suspect that we can't actually work out how he does it!
After the live show, there was a repeat of a previous show where he principly did two things. One was to read people - faces, body language etc and the other was to remember lots of stuff - like the Greater London A-Z.
Paul Daniels was quoted on Radio today as saying there were 99 different ways of achieving that result.
As for "who is Derren Brown?" - have bumped into him once. I've never been to see one of his shows, nor am i likely to!
But that's a personal choice...
Quote from: picsfor on September 10, 2009, 06:57:36 PM
Paul Daniels was quoted on Radio today as saying there were 99 different ways of achieving that result.
Yeah he said that to anybody who would listen before the stunt too. I wonder if any ex magician has ever sounded so bitter and sad. "I could have done that. If I'd thought of it."
Even now we know what the trick looked like there are loads of ways he could have done it. But it's a very clever piece of entertainment. Especially as a trailer for his new series.
Quote from: Jonathan on September 11, 2009, 07:44:23 AM
Quote from: picsfor on September 10, 2009, 06:57:36 PM
Paul Daniels was quoted on Radio today as saying there were 99 different ways of achieving that result.
But it's a very clever piece of entertainment. Especially as a trailer for his new series.
I think you take it there - no real come back to that.
Watching the explaination now. Flippin' adverts. Nothing else of any interest on. :(
Edit: That was an hour of my life wasted. Think i'll drown the old grey cells in beer after that. :beer: :beer:
how was it done then? missed the explanation :)
Quote from: Trickee on September 11, 2009, 10:50:26 PM
how was it done then? missed the explanation :)
basically he got a group of people to do it, got them to go into state of mind and just jot things down using free hand and not much control of what they were writing, first just to let the pencil do what ever it wanted on a paper then write numbers ...
short version, someone might put it better, or its bound to be on the channel 4 website like the iplayer version.
As I saw it, baring in mind I had to watch the +1 repeat cos I fell asleep. Actually I missed chunks of the repeat too!
Anyway, a group of people analysed the last years balls and wrote down in this subconciuos state what they thought the result of each ball would be, then took the average.
That or he messed with the machine.
These explanations make it as clear as mud for me :D Think I'll take a look on Channel 4 catch up later - the advantage of that being you can fast forward to the important bits and only waste a few minutes of your life :2funny:
It is a shame that he did not wanted to tell straight away how he done it. He is obviously milking this stunt a bit more. The explanation given was full of misdirection. The theory behind that system works only with a huge number of people (in the tens of thousands). It will never accurately work in a small group of 24. :D
Quote from: Simple on September 12, 2009, 10:05:41 AM
that system works only with a huge number of people (in the tens of thousands). It will never accurately work in a small group of 24. :D
Well he did it with 23 not 24 i think in the end since one of them couldn't do the drawing free hand thing.
In the earlier experiments, the group of 24 worked out and wrote down the final numbers. In the last one only Derren Brown worked out the average and the 24 never saw the numbers until he revealed them after the draw.
I don't believe a word of it. The average of mubblings of 20 odd people...piffle. So next week those twenty three people are going to get together without him and make a fortune :D
The maths just doesn't work. Studying the past wins and peoples favorite number patterns helps the odds a tad maybe to only get a number that most 'people' would put forward. But this number he picked nobody public won. The odds on that are just crazy! Just a trick, maybe just light sensitive sections on the balls, lasers or simple optical fiber lights to add on any numbers that come up to the balls. We're photographers, we know a variation of this process. :)
Quote from: DaveB on September 15, 2009, 09:32:05 AM
Just a trick, maybe just light sensitive sections on the balls, lasers or simple optical fiber lights to add on any numbers that come up to the balls. We're photographers, we know a variation of this process. :)
I don't put numbers on my balls but then, I've only got two!!! ::) :2funny:
I thought it said on the radio that this first explanation was just another bit of mis-direction aimed at bringing in viewers to the next shows. It is clearly nonsense as an explanation as the guesses of 24 people have no relevance to the workings of a machine making selections!
been a bit of trouble in a local pub round here that uses acts on stage recently. A mate of mine went up to perform and they said "You`re not a hypnotist are you?". He said no a singer - why? The guy said "Well the last one that came here put a load of people in a trance, got them prancing round the stage as horses, then he tripped and fell off shouting "dump" at the top of his voice. We`ve been cleaning up ever since"
Err sorry - wrong thread - i`ll get my coat ;)
I can't believe the number of people on other sites discussing whether Derren Brown's method would work.
IT WAS A LIE. Pure and simple. I'm betting on split screen now.