Right my DCmag is due for renewal in a couple of months, so I am thinking whether to renew it and re-read the subjects presented in a slightly different way or go to a new mag and see if there are new ideas!
Therefore the question are?
- What in your expieriences is the best mag or are the all the same
- What in your expieriences is the best mag or are the all the same
Is it really worth getting a mag - I personally still for me think it is
Have'nt bought a camera mag in ages. I found they took about ten minutes to read the bits I was interested in so seemed a bit expensive! For content I always found Photography Monthly had the most of interest. All magazines re-hash the same stuff and the news items are freely available on line - put the money aside each month and it'll add a bit to your camera fund ::)
They all recycle the content, but IMHO DC Mag is the worst of the them all for how often they do it and without much change to the theme and writer/expert.
I prefer practical photography out of them all. In fact I have just taken another subscription out after leaving alone for a year.
I gave up on DCM ages ago and moved to Outdoor Photograhy, find it far more nteresting for what I want to know
I have recently purchased a copy of Out Door Photography and thought it was very good. All the others seem to say very much the same thing all the time infact if you started a subscription to one of them today for 12 months you will just about cover everything untill they start repeating
themselves again. :legit:
the only mag I buy now is digital SLR photography its the only one that takes me longer than 15 mins to read every article
I also like Outdoor Photography. Really excellent work and lots of interesting in-depth features.
Occasionally I look at Black and White Photography - once every few months I find they have some useful tips on toning and the like and very good featured TOGs.
But my regular read is Amateur Photographer. I like the new style, especially the 'How I took this picture' sections from the resident pros. And they have a much more diverse range of photography, not just digital or flavour of the month stuff. They were the first mag I saw starting to argue that we should look again at natural landscapes with water that looks like water and not milky froth, for example, and they regularly feature pictures taken on film.
Haven't bought a Mag in over a year. I still go to the newstand, leaf through them and move on. Other than reviews of new equipment, there doesn't appear to be anything new under the sun.
Outdoor Photograhy, Good read and not full of junk!
I must admit I probably won't renew my DCM subscription but I have taken out one for Amatuer Photographer which is a lot more interesting to read and has a lot of useful stuff in. Also it's weekly which considering DCM takes about 20 minutes to read from cover to cover is a bonus!
Hewwo from Windy Sheffy,
Have to say,DCM is predictable and boring,but i do find the discs worthwhile,as for the mag content,well,its C R A P,and my sub will not be renewed.
However,i would deffo recommend Digital Photo,its punchy,has lots of hands on techy advice,and i generaly find it a good read,,,,,,
i also enjoy my monthly Sheffield River Wideners Club Gazette !!
OWLS ROOL ok
I've a subscription with Black and White Photography mag and get Amateur Photographer every week. All the others seem to be a bit samey.
Nick
http://www.isubscribe.co.uk/title_info.cfm?prodid=12719&gclid=CLLnyYuquJwCFUYA4wodh18XoA
just looked at a preview of outdoor photography-well impressed the quality of the pictures are stunning and a reasonable price. :)
I find most magazines very 'Samey'. When I occasionally read one, note read not buy one, I always have the feeling I've read it before, They all go through the same cycle of Special Features, and promise unattainable levels of expertise. It's a bit like Golf and Angling magazines, two other pastimes that I indulge in, I always thought that if I took all those magazines together and did what they advise I would eventually be someone who regularly caught specimen fish, got gold medals in every photographic exhibition whilst playing off scratch. But it doesn't seem to work like that :-[, so I just bumble along without them and enjoy myself :D.
P.S. I do buy Black + White Photography. For two reasons Eamonn Mcabe, a favourite photographer of mine is a staff writer and in the main it's written in an adult style, no mention of words like fab, wow, togs, blads or Twitter etc. ;). That's an age thing I suppose.
I buy most magazines for the year and have now found the same sort of things in them that were there last year,however I do now have a very large collection of free CD and if I actually looked at them my photography might improve. I did get Digital Photo this month because of the title page how to shoot perfect landscapes, and inside they say that 50% of modern photography occurs on the computer.
Sandy
Hi Folks.
When I went digital I was buying just about every "Howto" magazine on the stand. It soon became obvious that these magazines were governed by the seasons ("How to make the most of Autumn colours" etc.) and I soon became weary of them.
There are 4 Magazines I now buy regularly;
Amature Photographer
BJP
Photo Pro
Professional Photographer
I find the articles of more interest, the reviews more thoughtfull and the photography can be inspirational.
Graham. :)
I don't subscribe to any magazine publication, but do buy them on a failry regular basis 'just for something to read' and the mag tends to be DCM or Practical Photography. Having purchased both mags over the past 2 years they definitely repeat themselves and I'm bracing myself now for the 'Shoot great Autumn Colours' special feature that will no doubt appear ::)
Might investigate Amateur Photogrpahy though...
I keep having a thumb through the different magazines in the shops and have come to the conclusion that they all rehash the same ideas (with the occasional new idea). Not sure how much you choose to edit/alter photos in software afterwards, but perhaps a mag looking at software may be an alternative?
The only one I tend to buy (but not every issue) is Photo Plus as it's for canon only. You can pick up some useful tips in it occasionally but tend to get it just to read if i'm travelling on the train at work. When i'm not driving it that is. :2funny:
Just had a look at a copy of amatuer photographer, seems to be mostly ads & the only thing of great interest was the reader photos which are good but i am sure I could be just as interested in online galleries at zero cost. Seen a couple of copies of photoplus and there are some tips to be had but it seems quite basic.
My main problem with mags is that they seem to promote the newest gear and if you dont have the latest version of photoshop the tutorials are no good.
If I want to learn a new skill its easier to find something you actually want on the net rather than whats in this weeks mag that may not be of interest.
I stopped my subscription to DC Mag a couple of months ago and just did a feedback response to an email stating it was because of the way they had messed around with the website and customers. Just taken out a cheap rate trial of Photography Monthly and will probably look at that for a quarter. Quite a good read and cheaper I think but no disc which I miss. Might give them all a break then as they do get a bit repetitive.
I only buy the occasional mag if its has a subject or feature/review of kit that interests me. Otherwise, as others have said, mags are far too repetitive and cyclical - How to Shoot: Autumn Colours/Winter Scenes/Spring Colour etc.
Mind you, reading recent issues of AP have shown up a severe fault in my technique - apparently I am supposed to use my camera "at arms length" when composing with the rear screen...
This month I am a fan of Photography Monthy only because they printed a small picture of mine that was on their website ( Which I had forgot about because its another terrible website ) )and was apparently in the best 100 pictures for their 100th Magazine. Its called ( Townenders by Dave Wilson from Leyland ) you can vote for me if you like and I could win £ 250 but to be honest there are some far superiour pics to mine so good luck to the winner ! ............... :legit: By the way no payment for the use of my picture.... :'(
I used to buy "Black and White photography" almost religiously, but this magazine fell into the hole that DCM plunged down, that being the one marked "Article regurgitation". Same old, same old.
I also used to buy Amateur Photography regularly, but after the back page columnist "Roger Hicks" became less frequent with his articles, I gave up on this one as well. Thankfully, the local library gets this, so I can catch up on Rogers scribblings when they're published. :)
I notice that in the current DCM mag that a 70/200mm lens "Gives great depth of field."
What the hell does that mean? Great = Lots of
Great = Good
Either way it makes little sence!
The only reason I read the "How to" mags now is to play spot the balls up!
Graham. :)
Quote from: Graham on August 23, 2009, 06:14:08 PM
I find the articles of more interest, the reviews more thoughtfull and the photography can be inspirational.
Graham. :)
That's what I told my mother when, as a teenager, I was caught with the penthouse mag. Those forum letters were so plausible.
Quote from: hevans on August 28, 2009, 08:33:36 AM
Quote from: Graham on August 23, 2009, 06:14:08 PM
I find the articles of more interest, the reviews more thoughtfull and the photography can be inspirational.
Graham. :)
That's what I told my mother when as a teenager I was caught with the penthouse. Those forum letters were so plausible.
:-[
Quote from: skellum ( Dave ) on August 27, 2009, 01:36:34 AM
This month I am a fan of Photography Monthy only because they printed a small picture of mine that was on their website ( Which I had forgot about because its another terrible website ) )and was apparently in the best 100 pictures for their 100th Magazine. Its called ( Townenders by Dave Wilson from Leyland ) you can vote for me if you like and I could win £ 250 but to be honest there are some far superiour pics to mine so good luck to the winner ! ............... :legit: By the way no payment for the use of my picture.... :'(
I've also had a photo printed in PM. Mine's 'Popped Cyclist'. I don't understand why this one was picked as I've got a couple of other shots with more votes and comments!
Nick
Who chooses what images are included in magazines sometimes puzzles me. Of course it's not a democratic decision, so whatever his/her particular idea of what a good image is, obviously influences what is used.
That was never more obvious than when all hell used to break out in discussions about POTD on DCM. Question why an image was chosen and the reaction was very touchy. I suppose it came from the fact that the choosers were journalists thinking they were photographers as well. You can be good at one or the other, but when you try to be both at the same time you mat end up being good at neither.
Question their photographic credentials and they get very 'hissy', and you get a PM telling you they've been a photographer for x number of years and have been commissioned on several occasions to do freelance work, which makes them think everything is all right. ::)
I buy 1 or 2 Magazines most months - first choice are the photography ones - usually one with the most interesting (to me) cover - If nothing stands out I move on to Computer titles - then Camping/Caravaning then Fishing. They all seem to have one thing in common - governed by the seasons they become repetative. When I cant find something I go to ephotozine for a look see and if that fails I look at my Skype contacts for someone to natter with.
I`ve really gone to town this time. after reading this thread. i decided to take stock & have now cancelled my subs for DC mag, Photoplus & What dig camera.
Yep! it`s time for a change. Although i`ll probably still buy them from time to time. :D
Strangley enough I used to like Photography monthly when Willie Chueng who I have met ( who was also a good photographer) was editor.
I stopped buying it when Roger Payne took over as editor, I remember him from Photo Answers years ago when he was a spotty faced young magazine hack who knew nothing about photography and could not take a decent pic to save his life, he fairly quickly moved on to a none photo mag.
Now his is editor of PM but his photography has not improved much but he is still good at telling you how to do it. I guess I'm getting jaded with photo mags and "photo" journalists in my old age. Plus they rehash everything year after year, if it were not for digital reveloution and all the constant new equipment, they would not have anything to fill up there pages with. ;)
For the average 'how to take photos' and 'how to do photoshop' stuff, Practical Photography has improved a great deal recently. Although they're all much the same, really. None of them take more than about fifteen minutes to read, once you're used to the seasonal stuff (how to take photographs of autumn leaves etc).
If it's photographs plain and simple that you want to look at/learn from, then the three that I get most out of are:
-PhotoIcon
-American Photo
-Black and White Photography
The first two are really good at keeping you up to date with the most exciting photographers, and you'll see a lot of stuff that's not in your average mag.
B+W photgraphy is also fairly good, but sometimes caters a bit too much to the Leica school of photography, shots that are just technical excercises ie. "here's a perfectly sharp, expertly developed, beautifully toned print of something of absolutely no artistic value whatsoever"