....of your own pictures? Do you find that the ones you really like tend to get passed by and the ones you upload as an afterthought are the ones that get the comments? I suppose what I mean is a case of do we sometimes get a bit tied up with trying to get things technically right and ignore the fact that content is the mopst important thing. Of course, getting both right is the ultimate goal. I give you one of my most popular flickr uploads - over 1150 views and a number of favourited. Uploaded as part of a set taken at a very wet show last year with nothing done to it but a crop, I think there must be a lot of welly boot fetishists out there!
(http://cameracraniums.com/gallery/albums/userpics/normal_2754728368_5128928f40_o.jpg)
Have you found the same thing??
i totally agree with what you are saying i sometimes post a pic that i really like and think that it will stimulate some comments only to find that it gets passed over.
i think that sometimes the number of views can be attributed to the picture looking strange as a small thumbnail. i.e you cannot tell what the picture is until you view it good or not. of course not everyone here are active in making comments, probably because some pictures interest them more than others. just my 3 penneth :legit:
The most viewed picture are not always the best in photographic terms, but may invoke in people memories of times past and pets they have lost. In the case of your picture, a cute dog sitting next to his/her master, captures this moment perfectly and the fact that no genger or age can be attached to the wellie person, means they can see themselves in the picture. ;D
No I definitely think this one has more to do with the boots! ::)
Quote from: greypoint on August 13, 2009, 08:01:29 AM
....of your own pictures? Do you find that the ones you really like tend to get passed by and the ones you upload as an afterthought are the ones that get the comments? I suppose what I mean is a case of do we sometimes get a bit tied up with trying to get things technically right and ignore the fact that content is the mopst important thing. Of course, getting both right is the ultimate goal. I give you one of my most popular flickr uploads - over 1150 views and a number of favourited. Uploaded as part of a set taken at a very wet show last year with nothing done to it but a crop, I think there must be a lot of welly boot fetishists out there!
(http://cameracraniums.com/gallery/albums/userpics/normal_2754728368_5128928f40_o.jpg)
Have you found the same thing??
Sue I don't think you can be ......
Whoever we are there is an emotional tie of sorts to the pic that you have taken. Even if its a work thing you have invested a thought process into it, apart from the time and energy, you see what you want to in it, whereas somebody else will only see the picture itself and although they may understand the effort you went to take it they have nothing of themself invested in it and can like it (or dislike it) for the graphic that it is
I've lost count of the times I have printed and framed a picture to sell on the market ( thinking I am onto a winner ) only for it to be totally ignored. :'( :legit:
Yes I suppose there is that whole thing about what you put into it. If I was to take a stunning sunset in a popular and much photographed location I'd be really proud of it - others would think 'yawn, another cliched sunset'! ::)
Well I spose if you are proud of what you've achieved, ultimately that's all that matters - or do we all secretly do this to gain people's approval of our skill in our chosen hobby. How many shots have you taken that people don't see what you see in it? and you just want to say to them "look at it just look at it" and they still cant see it (I am thinking of my wife and the dogs a*** comment :D)
Ah - that's another 'photographer thing' I think - there are lots of pictures that a fellow photographer will praise for its composition, colours, tone and DOF - your Mum will say 'why on earth did you take a picture of a table leg?'!! :D
I think most of us want a little praise from time to time.
This is an interesting question, and especially relevant for me today. I recently sent off my fourth assignment for my OCA course. I was really unhappy with this assignment. Lots of things went wrong and I ended up with a collection with some pictures I was happy with and some I really wasn't. I have been absolutely dreading the feedback.
It arrived this evening and I spent an hour building up to opening it. The tutor said I was being too hard on myself and it was good submission. There were some pictures that were less successful than others but they were good examples of what the submission was about.
Now I wonder why I was so worked up about it. I still don't like all the pictures but they weren't that bad. I think I invested so much time in the exercise and had so many things go wrong that I lost all perspective.
I also have the opposite happen sometimes - pictures I really like get very little comment. Usually after a while I can see why.
I think the value of other people's opinion is'nt so much the fact you want praise, but, after you've spent a lot of time on something, you can find it hard to be objective and a fresh perspective can give you pointers for what could be improved next time.
Quote from: Eileen on August 13, 2009, 10:24:11 PM
I think most of us want a little praise from time to time.
This is an interesting question, and especially relevant for me today. I recently sent off my fourth assignment for my OCA course. I was really unhappy with this assignment. Lots of things went wrong and I ended up with a collection with some pictures I was happy with and some I really wasn't. I have been absolutely dreading the feedback.
It arrived this evening and I spent an hour building up to opening it. The tutor said I was being too hard on myself and it was good submission. There were some pictures that were less successful than others but they were good examples of what the submission was about.
That's because your idea of a good picture has been raised. If you cast your mind back to the first pictures you took and you thought they were great. Look at them now and you think they are rubbish. The further we push ourselves the more we expect. Well done on your course work and I know it will come right in the end. :tup:
Let's not forget the reverse that can never really be confirmed or proven. How many photos do you have in your collection that you think are substandard, but might actually be seen as brilliant by someone else? You can't ever know.
Quote from: spinner on August 14, 2009, 12:48:09 AM
Let's not forget the reverse that can never really be confirmed or proven. How many photos do you have in your collection that you think are substandard, but might actually be seen as brilliant by someone else? You can't ever know.
Very true! And I've got more than most! :-[
Using flickr and tagging your photos does give you a good idea of what people search for. I use the flickr stats option to see what's been looked at over the past couple of days. One of the most often searched for amongst my pics is 'norfolk terrier' [there's someone locally who shiows them so I have a fair few photos] - you would'nt think such a minority breed would have such a number of searches on it. My Norfolk pics appear on lots of websites all over the world - mostly without permission but they do link back - the ones I know about anyway!
Thanks OB. You are right in that my standards are higher than 18 months ago. But I also think that some pictures you take carry a lot of emotional baggage - the circumstances surrounding the actual picture, the effort you put in and the feelings you have about it, either good or bad, just get in the way of seeing clearly. A quote I heard somewhere recently goes something like: "You judge yourself by your intentions, while others judge you by your actions."
Personally I think I sometimes undervalue 'easy' pictures that just worked first time and overvalue ones I really sweated over. And of course if I really like the subject then that makes a difference also.
The next (final!!) section of the course focusses on story telling and subject matter. One of the first exercises to get us thinking about this is to gather some examples of pictures where the subject is more important than how they look, and vice versa. I think Sue's examples a great illustration of this (I don't mean that your pictures don't look good - I think they're great - but just that most people looking for pictures of Norfolk Terriers wouldn't be happy if they got a stunning portrait of a German Shepherd). Aesthetics are not unimportant but are a secondary consideration.
One of the things that makes photography so interesting to me is that there's always something to think about and you never stop learning. My favourite picture is always the one I am going to take next. :)
Think it can be easy to become obsessed with getting the techincalities right and forget that having a subject that's interesting [to some people anyway!] is the main point really ::)
I think it depends on why you are taking a particular shot.......for yourself because you like it or to sell. With any art form an artist creates from the heart but art is a personal thing and what one person likes another doesnt. If I had to paint for a raffle I would paint something that the majority of people would like but for myself my style is quite different.
To expand the point - if you put a photo in a competition and although the official judges didn't rate it but your fellow competitors voted it as the best what would your feelings be? ie whose view would carry the most weight?
Hewwo from Muggy Sheffy
I just assume everythings crap,,then i,m never surpised !
Seriously,i dont think it takes long to realise that other peoples comments dont really carry much weight either way,
its your own thoughts,or even better,those of non photographers that really count.
Shine On
I wrote some crits on the competition that runs monthly on DPG one month, to have the photographer of one of the shots complain about what I wrote. Essentially saying how difficult the shot was to take etc etc. Unfortunately the resulting picture was not that good, but he couldn't accept it due the effort he had put in and his resulting emotional attachment.
Some of you may remember that I went on a DCM day out at Yarak in Devon to take some bird of prey shots - and the one thing that has stuck in my mind from the day, was some thing Ben Birchall said. Essentially, do a quick pass of your shots and get rid of the real crap, then perhaps process some you really like, then leave the rest for a week or two. That gives you enough time to remove some of the emotion from the shots.
Funnily enough Rachael Decruze was also there - she had not long started I think. She was nice actually.
Quote from: anglefire on August 14, 2009, 09:08:22 PM
Essentially, do a quick pass of your shots and get rid of the real crap, then perhaps process some you really like, then leave the rest for a week or two. That gives you enough time to remove some of the emotion from the shots.
That's what I do and always have. The reverse is also true, that you take a series of shots, but on checking them you didn't get what you wanted, so you may be tempted to delete them, but leave them for a few weeks and you might see they are quite good. ;D
Thats true. Mind you, I autobackup to my external HD every day, so I have to make sure that I remove it from both places (Actually 3 cos my External HD backs itself up weekly to another HD!)
I tend to delete the rubbish quickly and then wait for a bit. It does help.
To answer your question Irv: it would depend (on whether I respected the judges or the other members more). And of course I'd be happy anyway if at least one group liked it.
In answer to your original question Sue, I guess my answer would have to be no. My latest post to my gallery, you said was the best of my series for you. I put in as an after thought and was thinking It would either get ignored or criticized so you have proven I can't judge my own stuff.
Others may disagree but I'd looked at them all and I liked the feel of that one best - not quite sure why 8)
Quote from: Eileen on August 14, 2009, 02:55:49 AMBut I also think that some pictures you take carry a lot of emotional baggage
Spot on.
I remember years ago showing a pic to my wife that I was very very proud of. It was some underwater junk.
"looks a bit soft" - yeah well there was a 12 foot surge - I was being rushed forward and back and shooting on slide film I only had chance to nail it
"and the colours are a bit off" yeah well I was using Kodak 100VS to up the shutter a bit - it was too dark for Velvia
"and you haven't framed it quite right" no but it was really cold - I was diving in a semi in 12 degrees so I was shivering a bit and my air was low so it was get that shot or leave it
"so why did you press the button.......?"
Which probably saved me a lot of embarrassment in the competition I was going to enter it for.
FWIW I almost never enter comps. If I do I often do badly - I'm a better judge of what I like and (more recently) what will sell than what will look good to a judge.
Am I the best judge of my own shots? Nope.
The latest one I put on Flickr, the helter skelter photo, looked ok-ish, but I could see the problems it had. Not a perfect shot, imo.
There's been lots of comments about the shot, nearly all saying "Thanks for the memories rekindled".
Golden rule as far as I'm concerned, never show, never enter for competition, never put up for judging and never offer up for exhibition any print or image that YOU are not satisfied with or completely sure about.
It's yours, you've visualised it, you've taken it, you've worked on it, but if you can't get the final result that you want, bin it. Don't offer it up with the hope that someone may like it, that's a real cop out.
If judges or any viewers don't like it so what? If you go down the slippery slope of taking pictures that you think will please the judge, or anyone other than yourself, you are on the road to mediocrity.
Quote from: ABERS on August 23, 2009, 10:56:56 PM
Golden rule as far as I'm concerned, never show, never enter for competition, never put up for judging and never offer up for exhibition any print or image that YOU are not satisfied with or completely sure about.
It's yours, you've visualised it, you've taken it, you've worked on it, but if you can't get the final result that you want, bin it. Don't offer it up with the hope that someone may like it, that's a real cop out.
If judges or any viewers don't like it so what? If you go down the slippery slope of taking pictures that you think will please the judge, or anyone other than yourself, you are on the road to mediocrity.
Abers that is great advice and I try to follow it but sometimes I ask SWMBO just in case I got it wrong ;)
SWMBO?
Quote from: ABERS on August 23, 2009, 10:56:56 PM
Golden rule as far as I'm concerned, never show, never enter for competition, never put up for judging and never offer up for exhibition any print or image that YOU are not satisfied with or completely sure about.
It's yours, you've visualised it, you've taken it, you've worked on it, but if you can't get the final result that you want, bin it. Don't offer it up with the hope that someone may like it, that's a real cop out.
If judges or any viewers don't like it so what? If you go down the slippery slope of taking pictures that you think will please the judge, or anyone other than yourself, you are on the road to mediocrity.
I think that's excellent advice IF your goal in entering a competition is to benchmark your best work and receive feedback on it. If on the other hand you're entering because you want to win then it's a whole different ballgame.
Quote from: ABERS on August 24, 2009, 08:03:26 AM
SWMBO?
And I had you down as a Rumpole fan..... :) SWMBO (http://www.idjit.net/swmbo.html)
QuoteI think that's excellent advice IF your goal in entering a competition is to benchmark your best work and receive feedback on it. If on the other hand you're entering because you want to win then it's a whole different ballgame.
Little point in entering a competition unless you want to win, but the same rules apply as far as I'm concerned, only enter if you are 100% satisfied with your image.
I'm still none the wiser about SWMBO, what does it stand for?
She who must be obeyed...I assume 8)
Quote from: greypoint on August 24, 2009, 12:29:41 PM
She who must be obeyed...I assume 8)
Well of course, my harshest critic! WASBIA. ::)
Quote from: ABERS on August 24, 2009, 02:14:56 PM
Quote from: greypoint on August 24, 2009, 12:29:41 PM
She who must be obeyed...I assume 8)
Well of course, my harshest critic! WASBIA. ::)
"What A Silly Billy I Am" perchance?
Graham. :D
I can think of a couple of others! :)
Quote from: Graham on August 24, 2009, 06:11:43 PM
Quote from: ABERS on August 24, 2009, 02:14:56 PM
Quote from: greypoint on August 24, 2009, 12:29:41 PM
She who must be obeyed...I assume 8)
Well of course, my harshest critic! WASBIA. ::)
"What A Silly Billy I Am" perchance?
Graham. :D
I can think of a couple of others! :)
I made that up as I went along, did you by any chance work on the Enigma at Bletchley Park? ;) Let's stop now!
Quote from: ABERS on August 24, 2009, 06:32:10 PM
Quote from: Graham on August 24, 2009, 06:11:43 PM
Quote from: ABERS on August 24, 2009, 02:14:56 PM
Quote from: greypoint on August 24, 2009, 12:29:41 PM
She who must be obeyed...I assume 8)
Well of course, my harshest critic! WASBIA. ::)
"What A Silly Billy I Am" perchance?
Graham. :D
I can think of a couple of others! :)
I made that up as I went along, did you by any chance work on the Enigma at Bletchley Park? ;) Let's stop now!
No I did'nt and yes let's!
Graham. :D
Quote from: ABERS on August 23, 2009, 10:56:56 PM
Golden rule as far as I'm concerned, never show, never enter for competition, never put up for judging and never offer up for exhibition any print or image that YOU are not satisfied with or completely sure about.
It's yours, you've visualised it, you've taken it, you've worked on it, but if you can't get the final result that you want, bin it. Don't offer it up with the hope that someone may like it, that's a real cop out.
If judges or any viewers don't like it so what? If you go down the slippery slope of taking pictures that you think will please the judge, or anyone other than yourself, you are on the road to mediocrity.
So Alan in a hypertethical situation
You have a book deal for £50 grand (you've already had your advance) and you are 3 images short.The deadline has past and they are gonna pull the plug. You have taken 3 passable shot this day you saying you wouldn't submit them. If so I have to say you're a bigger man than me as I would suspect most people would put them in.
And so would I Irv , hypothetically of course. I'm not immune to money. ;)
I'm an amateur so I won't have that to consider. If I was a professional however, I would hope I was enough of a professional to have met the deadline in the first place.
I have to say a very very good amateur though Alan :tup:
Quote from: ABERS on August 24, 2009, 09:02:20 AMLittle point in entering a competition unless you want to win
Interesting. I'd have thought there was more benefit in the process of entering and the feedback received than the prize/kudos of winning. A bit like when Italy started playing in the 6 Nations. I never understood why they turned up to get humiliated every year. Then a friend who is more into rugby than me said "how else would they improve?". They had no realistic chance of winning even a single game but unless they entered they never would have. A bt like sticking stuff up on Flickr - it's nice to make page 1 of Explore - but it's a lot nicer to have 10 people who know what they are talking about point out areas for improvement.
Re the pro/amateur thing.......a few friends run a monthly comp for wedding pics. All entrants are pros and the standard's reasonably high. There's no prize but for me the benefit is that you get proper critique from your peers. In June I entered a favourite snap and I won 8) July I entered another and it was absolutely slated by just about everyone. I don't think I got a single vote but I got some good honest feedback. June's bride saw the pic and said "oh that's nice" and at least 1 mag are going to be running it in their next issue. July's bride saw it and paid me £400 for a print. Now feedback's well and good. But £400 is £400 ;D
That proofs the point. Are you the best judge....? ABSOLUTELY!
Nothing as queer as folk.
If you like it, then someone somewhere will like it too.
If you hate it, then someone somewhere will like it.
If someone somewhere hates it, it is up to you to like it or hate it too.
:D
Quote from: Jonathan on August 25, 2009, 08:04:18 AM
Quote from: ABERS on August 24, 2009, 09:02:20 AMLittle point in entering a competition unless you want to win
Interesting. I'd have thought there was more benefit in the process of entering and the feedback received than the prize/kudos of winning. A bit like when Italy started playing in the 6 Nations. I never understood why they turned up to get humiliated every year. Then a friend who is more into rugby than me said "how else would they improve?". They had no realistic chance of winning even a single game but unless they entered they never would have. A bt like sticking stuff up on Flickr - it's nice to make page 1 of Explore - but it's a lot nicer to have 10 people who know what they are talking about point out areas for improvement.
Re the pro/amateur thing.......a few friends run a monthly comp for wedding pics. All entrants are pros and the standard's reasonably high. There's no prize but for me the benefit is that you get proper critique from your peers. In June I entered a favourite snap and I won 8) July I entered another and it was absolutely slated by just about everyone. I don't think I got a single vote but I got some good honest feedback. June's bride saw the pic and said "oh that's nice" and at least 1 mag are going to be running it in their next issue. July's bride saw it and paid me £400 for a print. Now feedback's well and good. But £400 is £400 ;D
There are competitions and competitions, I'm referring to the ones with the big money prizes where winning is somewhat like winning the lottery. Never any feed-back from them.
The fun ones are akin to a Sunday morning kick about and enjoyable as such, it's there that feedback is sometimes given, not always though.
Congratulations on the £400 touch.
I have recently concluded that my judgement about my pictures as something wide of the mark.
I am starting to post pictures now with a view to getting feedback for good or for bad.
My wife is my best judge - but then she has worked in an industry where she has been responsible for acquiring and using pictures in document production of various types.
Now i could only get her to spend some time reviewing my picture collection... She's on the Wii again giving losing nicely to Mr Murray. ::)