That is the question.
As the Shout box is not particularly suitable for a discussion, I will start a new topic.
Chris, if you want to chat, you simply do so. Start a new topic, say what you want to say, and if people are in a chatty mood, they will add their pennyworth's of thought.
This is indeed a photo site, but not everything that annoys, amuses or bemuses is photography related, so topics tend to vary.
Of the photography related topics, the ones about equipment seem to attract most reactions.
It would be great if a meaningful, insightful, lively discussion about photography could be started, so give it a go.
The existing threads about photography related subjects, seem to peter out after a while, but are revived regularly, so you could try that as well.
Good luck!
Here's something to chat about photographically.
Are you just influenced by your favourite photographer or do you copy his/her work. Have you ever plagiarised someone else's work or just stood back and admired it?
I can't say that I have a favourite photographer - I like a lot of photographers work, but I'm not of a mind to knowingly copy anyone, mostly because I can never remember their names to be able to do so.
I've certainly been influenced by Ansel Adams and Edward Weston (among others); the qualities that I associate with their work is the tonal range and clarity (by which I mean that the subject stands out unencumbered by extraneous matter and the composition concentrates the attention where the photographer wanted it). I do aim to achieve similar prints, but I've never knowingly copied. Except perhaps in terms of equipment - it was Ansel Adams that turned my mind towards large format film which I know use. It just makes things easier to achieve for me.
Too many to mention. If I see a picture that leaves an impact on me, I try to store it and come back to it quite often. (I do that with images from this site as well.) When I make pictures I try to recall similar images that had an impact on me and try to replicate that style for the subject in front of my camera. I learn from this and believe I become a better photographer because I do these things. I love it when people copy my pictures, because I believe that imitation is the greatest form of flattery.
I also find that over the last couple of years it is hard to come up with a style or a topic that is unique. It has, most likely, all been done before, so whatever unique thing you think you come up with is most likely been done before so learn from whatever and whoever has an impact on you.
Surely copying someone else's style (and several "someone elses" at that) is a certain way to never evolve a style of your own?
What surely is unique is the way you look at things, the things that stand out for you that others may not see. On that basis, showing the things you see in the way that you see them (which isn't necessarily how they appear "straight" seems to me to be the way to go.
I first started noticing photos way back in the late '70s especially the work of Jane Bown that appeared every week in The Observer, and in the sports section the images of Eamon McCabe. I soon found myself looking forward to the next week's edition.
I realised that there were images that were entirely different from the usual pictures that all and sundry were collecting from the chemists after weddings, christenings and holidays.
As time went by my interest expanded to other photographers with Don Mccullin, Elliot Erwitt and James Ravillious high on the list. You'll notice monochrome is the passion of each of these.
Whilst I don't set out to blatantly copy any of these I must admit when looking through the viewfinder I do mutter to myself that's an Erwitt or a Bown when I press the shutter. Never a Mccullin as I keep clear of war zones ::).
I would never set out to set up a picture of something that had taken my eye, that would be unforgiveable., although I've seen that happen.
There's nothing wrong with succumbing to an influence as long as it doesn't turn into a replication.
Quote from: ABERS on June 19, 2016, 09:46:29 PM
I would never set out to set up a picture of something that had taken my eye, that would be unforgiveable., although I've seen that happen.
Sorry, I'm being dense. Could you explain what you mean by this?
Quote from: StephenBatey on June 19, 2016, 10:22:58 PM
Quote from: ABERS on June 19, 2016, 09:46:29 PM
I would never set out to set up a picture of something that had taken my eye, that would be unforgiveable., although I've seen that happen.
Sorry, I'm being dense. Could you explain what you mean by this?
Perhaps I've not put it too well.
I see a picture of a still life that is unique, clever in its conception, well composed and expertly lit. It takes my eye and so I set out to copy all those attributes and make an image that replicates it exactly.
Hope that helps.
I have copied other people's styles and images before. It's how I learned. When I did photography at college a few years ago, we were gives themes and photographers to study and emulate. One such artist/photographer was Michael Wolfe. I liked his style and how his images made me feel.
Quote from: ABERS on June 19, 2016, 11:08:53 PM
I see a picture of a still life that is unique, clever in its conception, well composed and expertly lit. It takes my eye and so I set out to copy all those attributes and make an image that replicates it exactly.
Hope that helps.
Thanks. I understand now.
A quote from Jane Bown,
"Some people take pictures, I find them."
Are you a taker or a finder?
Do you come back from an outing with 4 or 500 images or perhaps 40 or 50 carefully considered shots, that you think 4 or 5 may make a picture worth looking at?
Jane Bown, another favourite.
I do not apply the scatter gun technique, unless I try to catch a swallow/house martin flying to and from its nest. (Never works, but I keep trying.)
I am a looker, hoping to find and then become a taker. Two or three shots per 'find.' Still a long way to go, but I think I am getting better at it.
This is one of the shots I took last Sunday. Definitely 'found,' albeit not original, as wedding photographers went there before me. I have not seen any of those shots, so definitely not an imitation.
(http://cameracraniums.com/gallery/albums/userpics/11140/normal_Flight_L_meer_1430_fort_bij_Edam_mono_sh.jpg) (http://cameracraniums.com/gallery/displayimage.php?pid=19185&fullsize=1)
Quote from: ABERS on June 22, 2016, 03:13:51 PM
A quote from Jane Bown,
"Some people take pictures, I find them."
Are you a taker or a finder?
Do you come back from an outing with 4 or 500 images or perhaps 40 or 50 carefully considered shots, that you think 4 or 5 may make a picture worth looking at?
Both; It really depends on my mood, available time, as well as the subjects I find or decide to shoot. That said, I usually set out with the setting for a Single shot and flick to Continuous if I feel there may be something behaviour wise to be gained in a burst of shots.
Quote from: ABERS on June 22, 2016, 03:13:51 PM
A quote from Jane Bown,
"Some people take pictures, I find them."
Are you a taker or a finder?
Do you come back from an outing with 4 or 500 images or perhaps 40 or 50 carefully considered shots, that you think 4 or 5 may make a picture worth looking at?
Depends what I'm photographing - BIF, Motorsports and football (I've only done two of these, both work charity events) I tend to stick the camera on either slow (6fps) or high speed (12fps) to catch the right moment - but also try and use timing as going through 3 or 4000 shots is not fun!
Static subjects or people I tend to be more considered and take very few.
Quote from: ABERS on June 22, 2016, 03:13:51 PM
Do you come back from an outing with 4 or 500 images or perhaps 40 or 50 carefully considered shots, that you think 4 or 5 may make a picture worth looking at?
4-500 images - never have so far as I can recall.
40-50 - these days only when I'm out with a digital camera to record something (e.g. last Saturday we went to the Weald and Downland Open Air Museum, where they were re-erecting a timber framed building. I came back with 30 exposures made). I always aim for the best camera position etc. before making an exposure. My idea of "exploring the subject" is to use my eyes and feet and not the camera.
4-5 - that would be a large number when I go out with my view camera with the intention of serious photography. In general terms, if I'm not certain that I'd want to print the image at A3/12x16 or larger, I don't make the exposure. OK, sometimes I am disappointed by the result and don't print, but it's my aim not to waste an exposure.
I have to admit Anglefire that never having done much, if any, sports photography I forgot the necessity to engage the continuous drive button.
It makes you wonder what sort of expertise those cameramen of old had with their equipment. You know the ones I mean, they were all dressed in gabardine macs with a large belt around the middle and sporting a trilby hat The archive film of Pele's first world cup goal in Sweden shows three such elegantly clad blokes running onto the pitch to capture the moment as he extricated himself from the net. Happy days. ;D
Quote from: ABERS on June 22, 2016, 03:13:51 PM
A quote from Jane Bown,
"Some people take pictures, I find them."
Are you a taker or a finder?
Do you come back from an outing with 4 or 500 images or perhaps 40 or 50 carefully considered shots, that you think 4 or 5 may make a picture worth looking at?
I'd be in the finder camp, as sometimes I might take only a handful of photos whilst been out for over five hours. At other times I might take 600 plus photos but that's taking photos of Swifts, Swallows and House Martins. :tup:
I'm not sure I understand the distinction intended between take and find. In one very obvious sense, you can't take what you haven't found. I can understand "take" in the sense of pointing the camera almost at random and snapping away; and I can understand the concept of actually looking to try and find a worthwhile image. But surely there's also another step - arranging the technicalities to create the image on the print that you saw in your mind, rather than the one that a straight photograph would give you. Assuming that what you saw was, in Ansel Adams' phrase "a departure from reality".
I'm off too my old stomping ground in Tenerife on Sunday so will be 'taking' hundreds of images but will use a dozen only
Quote from: ABERS on June 23, 2016, 08:46:09 AM
I have to admit Anglefire that never having done much, if any, sports photography I forgot the necessity to engage the continuous drive button.
It makes you wonder what sort of expertise those cameramen of old had with their equipment. You know the ones I mean, they were all dressed in gabardine macs with a large belt around the middle and sporting a trilby hat The archive film of Pele's first world cup goal in Sweden shows three such elegantly clad blokes running onto the pitch to capture the moment as he extricated himself from the net. Happy days. ;D
Absolutely. They had some serious skills in the old days, both timing and focusing and of course exposure, though that is one that can be preset (As can focus to a degree depending on the subject)
When I "only" had a 5D - so about 5fps, I did a motorsport event and there was a corner with a dip in the road so the cars cocked a wheel and the aim being to capture the wheel at its highest point. I had to use timing to get it right as I could only take 1 shot before the moment had gone and actually it was quite good fun and did mean less shots to go through!
I actually rarely is 12fps - or at least don't do long bursts.