Camera Craniums: The Photography Community for Enthusiasts

General Category => General Photography => Topic started by: Beaux Reflets on December 23, 2015, 08:35:02 PM

Title: IMAGE QUALITY
Post by: Beaux Reflets on December 23, 2015, 08:35:02 PM
Reading the recent Shouts opens up interesting thoughts and questions upon where or what draws the line to determine " what is good Image Quality" and indeed; What is the best combination of Make, Sensor, and Lens to achieve images that deliver a "Quality Image".

OK., to a certain degree over the vast range of cameras available today the term 'horses for courses' probably applies to what an individual photographer's needs are, and what they personally consider as the level they wish to achieve or interprate as 'Quality of image.'

While I hate to think that I can never provide or achieve an image of exceedingly good Quality using Fuji gear  ;)  I am reminded that my little Fuji S8000fd provided quite a few shots that exceeded many folks expectation along side shots taken with fairly decent DSLR's.

So what actually constitutes "QUALITY" or Good image Quality?

:beer:
Title: Re: IMAGE QUALITY
Post by: anglefire on December 23, 2015, 09:03:10 PM
Very good question.

I've been looking through my old photographs taken on various cameras and lens combination going back to my Canon 350D through my 5D, 1DMk3 and 1Dx - and I'm amazed at the quality of even the 350D shots - though to be fair, I've bought good glass over camera's (Though bought them when money allowed!) as they tend to hold their value better than cameras.

As an example, all these here: http://www.mark.colston-online.co.uk/Barcelona/index.html were with my 350D and probably wth my 17-40f4

So, to answer in less words. Quality is more down to the lens - a better camera just allows you to capture the shot in more extreme circumstances.  I don't even think the sensor is that important as long as it has "enough" pixies and you can keep with its sensible ISO range.
Title: Re: IMAGE QUALITY
Post by: Oldboy on December 23, 2015, 10:04:15 PM
I don't think it matters what camera, sensor or lens you use, as all can be used to produce a quality image. Think of lenses, cameras and sensors as tools you use to produce your masterpiece. While Rembrandt used various brushes and paints to produce his images you use different tools to do the same job. Think of Reinardina and the way she uses software to change her picture into an old master painting.  Her original image may not be quality but rather just, 'run of the mill' picture which wouldn't standout. By using Photoshop's tools she has turned it into a quality image. So, a quality image is what you see in your minds eye and cameras are just the tools you use to make it real.  :tup:
Title: Re: IMAGE QUALITY
Post by: jinky on December 24, 2015, 08:11:31 AM
I agree that it`s not the type of camera that always "makes" an image and the subject content / composition and other elements are the key. Also that it`s better to capture the image you see and want to keep with whatever camera is to hand and even a cheap compact is better than none at all to capture the moment. My comments in the shouts were more about those  magical moments when you had all the time in the world to catch a fantastic image but were limited by the fact that you`d gone with a carry on bag leaving the dslr at home. The panoramic shots I do with my compacts are clever and at first glance can be impressive but on closer inspection and even in print at times lack that detail I can get with a few shots stitched from my dslr. Night shots rendered a little too painterly and also not getting that killer bokeh / really shallow depth of field are really highlighted when I compare my LX100 1.7 aperture shots with my 50mm 1.4 Nikon lens too. Still it`s nice to have the choice sometimes and for daylight touristy shots it`s a blessing not to have the big backpack or be told I have to leave it at a flimsy security point when I go in somewhere!
Title: Re: IMAGE QUALITY
Post by: Karen on December 24, 2015, 09:08:35 AM
I certainly didn't mean to imply there was anything wrong with Fuji it just wasn't for me at the end of the day. It definitely has a lot going for it but now Ive had experience of both I prefer my DSLR.
Title: Re: IMAGE QUALITY
Post by: SimonW on December 24, 2015, 09:12:34 AM
Quality - you know it when you see it!

Some images are all the better for intentional blurr, being mostly out of focus, having (added) noise and so on. And some very clearly aren't. So does the same scene look better with or without any of these "defects"? Different people viewing the same image will often disagree....
Title: Re: IMAGE QUALITY
Post by: Hinfrance on December 24, 2015, 10:32:20 AM
Quote from: Karen on December 24, 2015, 09:08:35 AM
I certainly didn't mean to imply there was anything wrong with Fuji it just wasn't for me at the end of the day. It definitely has a lot going for it but now Ive had experience of both I prefer my DSLR.

I don't think you did Karen. Obviously you prefer the DSLR, and it is personal preference.

I'm a completely in agreement with Paul about bokeh and DOF, although to a large extent these can be added in PP if desired. I also agree with Mark about lenses - without a doubt my two best and sharpest lenses are my primes. Actually, I don't have any issue with any of the comments so far - they're all valid.

It is true that the few photographs of mine we have on the walls were all taken with a DSLR. Although I have one I would like to hang that was taken with my now sold Fuji HS20. My next camera purchase will definitely be a bridge camera, and probably another Fuji.

Off now to start the preparations (food, mainly) for tomorrow. Merry Christmas everyone  :tup:
Title: Re: IMAGE QUALITY
Post by: anglefire on December 24, 2015, 08:19:10 PM
As I've already said, a "better" camera allows some shots to be caught that a lesser camera can't - generally fast moving subjects are easier to get with a fast camera and decent lens - and shots in low light to name but too.

My 350D was good to about ISO800 - 1600 was only just ok, my 5D good to ISO3200 with the right subject, Mk3 to about the same really, but the 1Dx can produce stunning shots even at ISO25600 - especially when printed out.

But I also agree that a small compact or even a phone is the right camera if it is the one you have to hand at the time!

I certainly wouldn't begin to seriously suggest any one make was better than any other as it all very much personal preference (Though Canon is best  :legit:)