Camera Craniums: The Photography Community for Enthusiasts

General Category => General Discussion => Topic started by: stevebedder on May 30, 2009, 08:11:13 PM

Title: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: stevebedder on May 30, 2009, 08:11:13 PM
Evening All,

How are you this fine sunny day?

Got back from Cornwall in the early hours of this morning, had a great time and have been gardening all day as the lawn resembled a jungle!!

Anyway, whilst away I managed to give the new camera a good run out and love it - but what I am even more impressed with is the Canon software (Digital Photo Professional) that came with it! It's superb for editing your images.

It's not quite Photoshop, it doesn't have all the bells & whistles and I will still use Photoshop - but for editing levels, contrast, saturation, cropping etc it's superb!

Anyone else using DPP or other similar camera vendor software? How do you think it compares to PS?

Cheers

Steve
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: Mick on May 30, 2009, 11:43:55 PM
Quote from: stevebedder on May 30, 2009, 08:11:13 PM


Anyway, whilst away I managed to give the new camera a good run out and love it - but what I am even more impressed with is the Canon software (Digital Photo Professional) that came with it! It's superb for editing your images.

It's not quite Photoshop, it doesn't have all the bells & whistles and I will still use Photoshop - but for editing levels, contrast, saturation, cropping etc it's superb!

Anyone else using DPP or other similar camera vendor software? How do you think it compares to PS?



Hi Steve.  Hope you're getting on ok with the new camera.  ;)   

I use DPP all the time now, and have done so for quite a while.  The only thing that's missing for me is a straighten tool.  Apart from that it's superb software.  Updated to the latest version (3.6.1.0) a short while back, and was pleased to see they added Highlight and Shadow sliders.

DPP is getting better all the time, and don't use any other software  at all unless I need to straighten a horizon etc.
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: stevebedder on May 31, 2009, 12:17:53 AM
Funnily enough Mick I had the same conversation with my father-in-law this afternoon.

He uses DPP too and we both mentioned that it is missing a straighten\rotate feature.

Maybe one for the Canon wishlist?

I'm running 3.5.0.0 which came with the camera, will have to download the latest version!

Steve
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: anglefire on May 31, 2009, 07:13:21 AM
I must admit, I've not used DPP for a long time - I used to use it all the time, but since getting CS3 (Now 4) I find ACR does everything I want - especially now CS4 has adjustment brushes and such like.

But many swear by it - like everything, seamingly, these days there is not one right way of doing stuff!
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: Mick on May 31, 2009, 07:42:16 AM
Quote from: anglefire on May 31, 2009, 07:13:21 AM

But many swear by it - like everything, seamingly, these days there is not one right way of doing stuff!


Absolutely Mark.  Use what works best for you is what I say.  ;) 

I only have Elements 6 anyway, and haven't bothered going for the full blown PS.  Obviously DPP is great for straight forward adjustment and conversion, and resizing.  but you can't do anything selectively, ie adjust part of a image.  That aside though, considering it comes free with the camera, it's fantastic.  :tup:
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: bones615 on May 31, 2009, 08:53:49 AM
I am using Dpp all the time, it does all I need & I very rarely open PS. Mick posted a link to some tutorials for Dpp which may be basic but you can pick up some tips.
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: anglefire on May 31, 2009, 01:13:05 PM
The fact that DPP is so good seems to surprise some people - probably because it is free - unlike Nikons software, which I beleive you have to pay for and it doesn't seem to be so popular. (I not used it so, am onlygoing on what I hear!  ::))
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: Walkthru on June 04, 2009, 06:24:49 AM
Hi guys,

Not being a Canon user, I obviously don't own DPP, but being a Nikon user, I have Nikon Capture NX2 (which I use in conjunction with PS CS3), and it is a fabulous program.  NX2 does have a straighten tool.  It uses u-point technology where you can do selective adjustments, though you cannot do selective adjustments to exposure.  I do hear that CS4 now utilizes u-point technology too, and you can do selective adjustments to exposure - great for improving underexposed skies I guess. 
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: Oldboy on June 04, 2009, 09:09:56 PM
Quote from: anglefire on May 31, 2009, 01:13:05 PM
The fact that DPP is so good seems to surprise some people - probably because it is free - unlike Nikons software, which I beleive you have to pay for and it doesn't seem to be so popular. (I not used it so, am onlygoing on what I hear!  ::))
Nikon's free software is rubbish, because the cameras are so good!  :2funny:  :2funny: :legit:
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: anglefire on June 05, 2009, 07:46:09 PM
Thats cutting Oldboy - though I couldn't possibly agree with the second part of your statement  :2funny:

And yes, CS4 and Lightroom 2 can do adjustments within the RAW module. And it works very well a lot of the time. Saves doing two RAW conversions mostly.
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: guest4 on June 06, 2009, 02:22:23 AM
Pentax and Sam sung dslrs come with a free version of Silkypix Raw converter which is excellent. It has all the functions but its been hobbled so it'll only work with the files from the actual make of camera.

That said, I'm really too lazy to go about doing complex RAW conversions so tend to do it all in PE4.
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: anglefire on June 06, 2009, 10:58:01 AM
I did download the trial of Silkypix sometime ago - on Craftysnappers recommendation really, and it wasn't for me if I'm honest - may be I didn't try it enough - but also you sometimes just like something else and it works!

Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: Walkthru on June 08, 2009, 08:42:54 AM
Mark - what I actually wanted to know about CS4 is, that within ACR, can you do a selective exposure adjustment to the sky, without affecting the foreground, or vice-versa for instance.

...........and I'm sorry to disagree OB, but Capture NX2, , is actually a very good image processing program, if you take the time out to master it (it can be a little slow at times however - but you tend to forgive that when you can do selective adjustments on your shots).
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: anglefire on June 08, 2009, 10:04:23 PM
I've done a screen grab from ACR selective adjustment tab.

(http://www.general.colston-online.co.uk/acr.jpg)

I have it set to see the mask - which you can see over the beach - I've also done a grad filter on the sky - but there is no mask on that.

You can see what you can adjust - and you can do more than one, so that different parts of the image have different adjustments.

Does this help?
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: Oldboy on June 08, 2009, 10:18:48 PM
Quote from: Walkthru on June 08, 2009, 08:42:54 AM
Mark - what I actually wanted to know about CS4 is, that within ACR, can you do a selective exposure adjustment to the sky, without affecting the foreground, or vice-versa for instance.

...........and I'm sorry to disagree OB, but Capture NX2, , is actually a very good image processing program, if you take the time out to master it (it can be a little slow at times however - but you tend to forgive that when you can do selective adjustments on your shots).
Nothing wrong with Capture NX2, but you have to pay for that or had the special offer with the top cameras. What you get with a normal cameras is Picture Project, which is rubbish.  >:(
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: skellum on June 09, 2009, 01:25:36 AM
I know in this day and age it is easy to rely on computer programs to make your pictures better but if the photographer were to spend more time getting used to using the camera / lenses & filters then a basic program would be all that is needed to make a few adjustments unless you want to photoshop it to death and make it look like something on Mars and probably unprintable.
For me it is still rewarding to see an image that only needs minor adjustments strait from the camera and the pleasure of knowning you may just becoming master of your expensive equipment as apposed to sorting it out on the computer at home. ( Having said all that I spend to much time on the programs anyway  ;D )  :legit:

Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: Walkthru on June 09, 2009, 01:58:36 AM
Firstly, thanks Mark - the screenshot really helps.

Dave.....I guess it is down to personal preference in a way, but sometimes, it is almost impossible to get it right in-camera, so a little adjustment via your software can help to tweak something that otherwise would look maybe not quite right.  What's the point of digital if you can't utilize all of its' possibilities?  Incredible dynamic range is one of those things that our eyes have that cameras don't, so if we can use software to decrease that gap, and produce something closer to what we see in reality, then all the better.  This is why HDR was invented, but it still has a long way to go yet in its' development (and more than likely, it will eventually be incorporated onto the processor of your camera & will probably negate, or reduce, the need for software processing).
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: skellum on June 09, 2009, 09:20:28 AM
As I said a few minor adjustments. :legit:
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: anglefire on June 10, 2009, 07:47:55 AM
Glad the screenshot helped!

The adjustment brush (And grad) can be very useful in ACR - I've been doing a lot of plantroom shots for work and often the background (Roof etc) are a bit darker than I'd like, so I use the adjustment brush to bring the shadows up a bit. Without using multiple flash guns its almost impossible to do - as there are also multiple light sources anyway. Plus the job is in London, and it was bad enough taking my tripod last week for the finished job! (I had been hand holding everything up till then - you know ISO 400, 1/6" F8 and 2nd curtain flash)
Title: Re: Camera Software vs Photoshop
Post by: Trickee on June 10, 2009, 08:35:51 PM
having gone through two 60 day trials i actually purchased capture NX 2. :tup: yes its slow >:( i think it must be poorly written for slower machines i have 2g ram and dual core processor and probably need twice the power to make it cruise. i have to give it the occasional break for it to catch up but the image quality that i get is much better than any other software that i have tried mainly because its matched to the output of Nikon cameras. the U-point features take some getting used to but as you click your way up the learning curve you realise how powerful the software is. Like all other software i am sure that updates will follow introducing more features that will require me to let the moths out of my wallet but that life :tup: