I belong to several other forums and in one of them, there's someone who continually posts images in the gallery that are really awful, as he cannot post process (and Im sure you all think that of some of my images too at times!!!). People make lovely comments about them to him, but Im sure they are just being kind. But are they really being kind? Should they not be more honest in a helpful way, advising how they can be improved or what hasn't quite worked? Im fairly new to the forum and never critique his images, as Im worried I will offend him and others who all seem to like him as a person.
What would you do? Shall I bite the bullet and give him helpful critique or continue to refrain from commenting? If it were my images, I would prefer some honest critique but they just tip toe round this guy, seeming to walk on egg shells.
I believe you should be honest but should find something to praise within the image, and start with that before pointing out the faults with humour. ;D
It could be, he is seriously trying to break the rules, and give new meaning to photography. Maybe just waiting to be discovered by some national gallery.
Is it a forum where people critique at all? Or is it just a back slapping sort of thing?
You could always send a carefully worded personal message, or say something like: I like the composition/colours/subject, you really captured something different (or whatever). If this was my shot, I'd probably up the contrast/saturation a little, or whatever else you think he should start with. Just drip feed, and not on every image he posts. See if there is any reaction from him or his friends.
Good luck.
Critique, ahhhhhh now that's a question as to whether or not offer this to a picture.
I do not like offering my view on someone else's picture as I feel that I am not qualified enough to do so.
My problem is I cannot beat around the bush, if something is crap I would say so, hence I never or very rarely say anything about another picture.
I must admit I bite my lip sometimes in the competitions, not only on here when you see something that is blatantly not correct but is getting the votes because it is a cutie picture or is a loose tongue in cheek representation of the brief. It is not that I think it is any better that mine but it just annoys, hence I just keep quiet about it.
As my tag line says, " you have to be in it to win! but winning is not everything it is participating that counts"
My view on this, over and out :legit:
Firstly you have to be qualified to pass comment. 'Let him without sin cast the first stone' :-[
People get quite huffy if you point out something within their image Simple things like a wonky horizon or a distracting highlight..
Keep clear.
Quote from: ABERS on April 29, 2014, 09:10:11 AM
Firstly you have to be qualified to pass comment. 'Let him without sin cast the first stone' :-[
People get quite huffy if you point out something within their image Simple things like a wonky horizon or a distracting highlight..
Keep clear.
Wise as ever.
Quote from: kerbside on April 29, 2014, 09:01:38 AM
I do not like offering my view on someone else's picture as I feel that I am not qualified enough to do so.
You don't need to be qualified to say what you like or don't like. Whether it's a old master painting or a photo by a member your opinion is just as valid. Remember, we all see thing differently and what you might see may be more correct than what I might see. :tup:
If you want to criticise one of my photos then go ahead but don't forget I have a big... :knuppel2:
As I said ABERS you have to be qualified in my view to offer critique, what qualifies you is another matter.
Quote from: kerbside on April 29, 2014, 09:01:38 AM
Critique, ahhhhhh now that's a question as to whether or not offer this to a picture
I do not like offering my view on someone else's picture as I feel that I am not qualified enough to do so..
after the last 'critique' discussion I am really reluctant to put my opinion in .
If it were me I would prefer honesty and constructive criticism, but then he/ she is not me.
As for being qualified, I believe that as photographers we are all qualified to make comment and support others. I don't need a masters degree to do that.
I really don't want to say too much in case anyone recognises the individual I am referring to (theres a couple of people on this forum that use the other one). What he does is takes various images of someone (the same 'model' each time) in various portrait poses. The images themselves are probably very nice for him, he 'experiments' with different lighting techniques but I can never see anything different about the lighting. He then 'cuts' the image and pastes it onto a plain background and it is this part that's awful! The edging is uneven and fake and often carried 'bits' of the old background with it.
I think he just needs to use a different 'cutting tool' and refine the edges differently. This would work a treat. I agree with Abers regarding being qualified to critique however you don't even have to know anything about photography to see his problem. I also like Reinardina's idea of a private message to him. If I get banished, so be it!
I strongly disagree with having to be qualified to criticise an image. Many art critics can't paint the side of a house never mind a painting, many food critics burn toast but can criticise others food. Many photographers take crap photos but they know what they like.
If an image is put up within an area of a forum that is asking for criticism then criticise if you feel it deserves it. If an image is posted within a general area, then be careful. :-X
Chris, I think anyone who also uses the other forum, will now know who you are talking about! You gave a very recognisable description of the photos this man uploads.
I do not like giving critiques, and that was the part I least liked in the competition on the old DGM site. Unless I was bowled over by a shot, I always was very bland and non committal.
I don't see anything wrong in giving constructive criticism and being helpful after all if he/she doesn't know that anything is wrong then how on earth can they hope to improve.
You say the some of the backgrounds are awful you could make some suggestions as to how they could improve the image, you could also download the image make some improvements and repost the image back into the thread stating how you made the improvements and you may find that they actually are grateful to you.
But that's just my opinion
Quote from: 2Beers on April 29, 2014, 02:29:07 PM
you could also download the image make some improvements and repost the image back into the thread stating how you made the improvements and you may find that they actually are grateful to you.
But that's just my opinion
Personally, if that happened to one of my images on here, I would be most annoyed. It is good Etiquette to ask first :tup:
Quote from: Beaux Reflets on April 29, 2014, 02:42:45 PM
Quote from: 2Beers on April 29, 2014, 02:29:07 PM
you could also download the image make some improvements and repost the image back into the thread stating how you made the improvements and you may find that they actually are grateful to you.
But that's just my opinion
Personally, if that happened to one of my images on here, I would be most annoyed. It is good Etiquette to ask first :tup:
A very select group of close digital photographer friends, could do that to an image of mine, without annoying me.
They'd have to email it to me though, as I would never forgive them if they posted it back in a thread somewhere.
Quote from: Reinardina on April 29, 2014, 05:29:42 PM
Quote from: Beaux Reflets on April 29, 2014, 02:42:45 PM
Quote from: 2Beers on April 29, 2014, 02:29:07 PM
you could also download the image make some improvements and repost the image back into the thread stating how you made the improvements and you may find that they actually are grateful to you.
But that's just my opinion
Personally, if that happened to one of my images on here, I would be most annoyed. It is good Etiquette to ask first :tup:
A very select group of close digital photographer friends, could do that to an image of mine, without annoying me.
They'd have to email it to me though, as I would never forgive them if they posted it back in a thread somewhere.
I have no problem with critique or others telling me how they think my photographs could be improved - for that is just a matter of opinion, and sometimes another opinion can be a great help towards improving my own capabilities. - I'm always willing to learn new tricks and improve my work.
I do however feel that every photograph belongs to the photographer who took it, so while expressing an opinion upon a particular photograph is acceptable, downloading and republishing (with or without alterations being made) without the owners consent is unacceptable.
If I cant say something constructive about whatever it is that I dont like I tend to say nothing. I use the word "personally" as every photograph is subjective. Mostly Im a stickler for sharp focussing and composition so thats what I mostly look at. However if its a stunner I say its a stunner. If people post their image then generally theyre happy with it.
QuoteI do however feel that every photograph belongs to the photographer who took it, so while expressing an opinion upon a particular photograph is acceptable, downloading and republishing (with or without alterations being made) without the owners consent is unacceptable.
I also agree with this statement, while I am happy to be given constructive criticism on any of my photographs, as I see this as another view/opinion and a way of me learning, I would not like someone to make changes without first asking. I do not feel anyone needs to be 'qualified' to comment or critique on my shot's at all either.
Im going in to the other thread........gonna message him and ask some questions first...here goes....
Late to the party as always, but my take is: don't. I've had more than enough flak in my time for saying what I thought about an image. Mainly it boils down to: this is what the person wants to do; it's what they enjoy doing. If they aren't interested in the slightest with trying to be artistic/convey an emotion/add your own reason here then why try to impose your standards (which are by definition inappropriate to them) on them? And the final killer - it's all subjective anyway. If they like it, end of story - nothing more to say. (I disagree with this strongly, but never debate it now.)
Putting it another way, if they like playing with cameras/testing lenses/taking snaps and being happy if they "come out" why upset them by trying to get them to take a different path in photography? All that unites photographers is using a camera or image capturing device; so it's really quite inappropriate to try to make them "better" photographers. From their point of view, you might give them more help by posting a tutorial on lens design than commenting on their composition.
I've met with this so many times - and there is some truth in it - that I now believe that in most cases for most photographers, you simply ignore their images if they are cringeworthily bad. I certainly make a point of never saying anything if an image has no redeeming features unless the photographer shows some promise in other offerings.
Many moons ago, I was loathe to offeer anything but positive comments about people pictures.
But now, i work on the premise that i only comment if i like the picture in the first place, or like the aim of the shot (sometimes people say what they were trying to achieve).
My comment works along the line as suggested by offering positive comments about the shot. Then I add in that for me, were I to have taken that shot, I would have done this differently or that differently. If I'm not too familiar with the photographer, I will finish with a comment about the beauty of photography being that we can all have our own individual take on a scene or pic and still enjoy anothers viewpoint.
When dealing with pros, it is easier, because you are never really complaining about a shot. More pointing out an issue that may have got overlooked in the workflow, as those posted on forums are rarely their best work...
If a person constantly takes bad pics - and they only ever seem to get good comment - ask yourself why? Do they have the ability to delete the negative ones? Or is it a case of you say nice things about my pics, and i'll say nice things about your pics in return?
Quote from: DigiDiva on April 29, 2014, 08:35:56 AM
I belong to several other forums and in one of them, there's someone who continually posts images in the gallery that are really awful, as he cannot post process (and Im sure you all think that of some of my images too at times!!!). People make lovely comments about them to him, but Im sure they are just being kind. But are they really being kind? Should they not be more honest in a helpful way, advising how they can be improved or what hasn't quite worked? Im fairly new to the forum and never critique his images, as Im worried I will offend him and others who all seem to like him as a person.
What would you do? Shall I bite the bullet and give him helpful critique or continue to refrain from commenting? If it were my images, I would prefer some honest critique but they just tip toe round this guy, seeming to walk on egg shells.
This is a bit of a mystery and a bit harsh??? Purely on your say so we are lead to believe somewhere out there exists a photographer who has no idea what he is doing. It would seem that others do not hold your opinion however. Is your negative opinion purely subjective or borne of an insight into the intricacies of post processing? Do you understand what he is trying to achieve, is his intent beyond your ken? Have you asked yourself any of these questions before 'helping' him? Perhaps he has a view that it would be interesting to step outside the box and produce something different.
It would be useful if you posted a link to his work so that we all could see what you're on about.
If you stick something on the internet it's fair game.
Quote from: Hinfrance on May 01, 2014, 08:36:13 AM
If you stick something on the internet it's fair game.
In what way?
If someone shares snapshots with family and friends on the Internet, they may feel upset if someone waded in, uninvited, to tell them where they go wrong, and how they can improve.
Maybe these photos should not be on a specific photography site, but not everyone may have found, or like, the 'non committal' photo sharing sites.
Quote from: Hinfrance on May 01, 2014, 08:36:13 AM
If you stick something on the internet it's fair game.
Fair game for what? :-\
Quote from: Reinardina on May 01, 2014, 08:43:51 AM
Quote from: Hinfrance on May 01, 2014, 08:36:13 AM
If you stick something on the internet it's fair game.
In what way?
If someone shares snapshots with family and friends on the Internet, they may feel upset if someone waded in, uninvited, to tell them where they go wrong, and how they can improve.
Maybe these photos should not be on a specific photography site, but not everyone may have found, or like, the 'non committal' photo sharing sites.
Fair game is, sadly, a geniune view point. It has long since been considered that if you post a pic on the internet on a photography forum, such as Flickr, unless you lock off the ability for people to comment - then you are fair game for critiquing whether you want it or not.
It is one of those ares of 'web etiquette' that has become 'de facto'. Is it written down anywhere? Not to my knowledge. But then, when is etiquette ever written down?
With any of these photography forums, there is always the option to make them private and allow only invited people to view the images - so if the shots are family pics not intended for critique - the account owner should either lock off comments or make the gallery/ album(s) private.
As for some one posting 'uninspiring shots' and getting loads of positive feedback, well that is/ was one of the reasons why Flickr interest wained. I know of people that worked on a 'you praise my shot and i'll praise your shot' principle - it distorted the 'views' or what ever measuring device Flickr used to indicate the popular images.
Most of my work is now submitted on 500px, and i seem to have a acquired some very positive comments (still not sure why) but when ever a comment comes in that says "lovely shot come and look at my stuff" I always ignore the comment. I can easily spend an afternoon or evening viewing the work of people I follow as it is - I don't need an excuse to look at peoples work.
Fair game for anything and everything, from praise to abuse, from sale to theft.
People don't seem to realise that the internet is not like a little private club, it's the most open and public arena there has ever been. I recall a minor celebrity once saying that it was like talking to your mates down the pub (he was referring to Twitter). Actually it's like standing on the top of the highest mountain with a huge PA system that the whole world can hear, but with the added bonus that what you say and do is recorded effectively forever.
As for 500px, I get the same sort of vague positive comments on there as I do anywhere else - just fewer of them (not that I get many anyway). The 500px rating system sucks too; if you don't keep on uploading pictures all your ratings decrease. I have had a couple of pictures selected for their Prime thingy, but no-one's bought anything, as far as I can tell.
I wouldn't do that to him. That would be rude and Im sure, in breach of the forum etiquette. Unless he is trying something that is very strange (and believe me I like strange) his images are horrid! In my eyes that is.....and I understand that he may be trying to achieve something different. And I understand my views are not everyone's. I just find it odd that no one says anything except really lovely things. Nothing constructive I must add.
Quote from: DigiDiva on May 01, 2014, 06:27:15 PM
I wouldn't do that to him. That would be rude and Im sure, in breach of the forum etiquette. Unless he is trying something that is very strange (and believe me I like strange) his images are horrid! In my eyes that is.....and I understand that he may be trying to achieve something different. And I understand my views are not everyone's. I just find it odd that no one says anything except really lovely things. Nothing constructive I must add.
Why keep telling
us?? Tell
him that his work puzzles and annoys you and that you cannot understand it and why so many other people appear to enjoy it.
You never know, he may be looking at your pictures and wondering the same thing, in that case wouldn't you like to know that?
I treat the comments I make on the internet the same as I would in a conversation on the street. So If I meet a lady friend that has just bought a new dress that is the most ugly thing and unflattering on her, makes her bum look enormous etc. I will not tell her. If someone is proud of a picture they put up on the internet, and it is the most ugly thing and makes the people in it ugly etc. I will not tell them. The other thing is that you are not likely to know much about the person, is he handicapped, learning disabilities, illness, very young? So unless you can build up a bit of "friendship" via a forum like this it is in my opinion better to say nothing.
Well said Simple, an interesting aspect. After hearing what you have all said so far, Im leaving well alone!
Quote from: DigiDiva on May 02, 2014, 07:13:14 AM
Well said Simple, an interesting aspect. After hearing what you have all said so far, Im leaving well alone!
Now that this problem is solved, you'll have some time to show and delight us with your pictures.
For such an active person, your 'picture count' is dismal.
To quote Elvis:
"A little less conversation, a little more action please."
I hardly ever post to gallery here as very few people look. And many others find it pointless sadly. I use a different forum for that and leaving comments on images. I belong to a fewforums and have learned what areas are active in each one and tend to stick to that . if Iit werent for people chatting there would be no forum . this was a liveely debate and to be fair.....plenty people had lots to say here.
Blimey - lively is certainly the word!
Oh well - back to viewing other threads :beer:
Quote from: DigiDiva on May 02, 2014, 12:17:05 PM
I hardly ever post to gallery here as very few people look. And many others find it pointless sadly. I use a different forum for that and leaving comments on images. I belong to a fewforums and have learned what areas are active in each one and tend to stick to that . if Iit werent for people chatting there would be no forum . this was a liveely debate and to be fair.....plenty people had lots to say here.
You will be surprised, quite a few folk do look at the gallery pages, and increasing participation tends to make things less pointless ;)
Quote from: DigiDiva on May 02, 2014, 12:17:05 PM
I hardly ever post to gallery here as very few people look. And many others find it pointless sadly. I use a different forum for that and leaving comments on images. I belong to a fewforums and have learned what areas are active in each one and tend to stick to that . if Iit werent for people chatting there would be no forum . this was a liveely debate and to be fair.....plenty people had lots to say here.
Hardly ever? Having searched the galleries I would say never. It's a shame you reserve all your photographic expertise for other forums and just keep CC for chuntering on about things.
Quote from: DigiDiva on May 02, 2014, 12:17:05 PM
I hardly ever post to gallery here as very few people look. And many others find it pointless sadly. I use a different forum for that and leaving comments on images. I belong to a fewforums and have learned what areas are active in each one and tend to stick to that . if Iit werent for people chatting there would be no forum . this was a liveely debate and to be fair.....plenty people had lots to say here.
Personally I think posting your photos is the main point of the site. I enjoy seeing others shots and to be honest if we all stopped posting what would be the point? I look at the galleries and try to leave as many comments as I can. I dont want a photography site that has no photos. I think we have a nice mixture of chat and images but we all have to work at it or whats the point Mick keeping it going?
Quote from: DigiDiva on May 02, 2014, 12:17:05 PM
I hardly ever post to gallery here as very few people look. And many others find it pointless sadly. I use a different forum for that and leaving comments on images. I belong to a fewforums and have learned what areas are active in each one and tend to stick to that . if Iit werent for people chatting there would be no forum . this was a liveely debate and to be fair.....plenty people had lots to say here.
many others find it pointlessYou blindly follow the advice of many others, without trying things out for yourself?
It's up to us, the members, to make this site what we want it to be. If everyone turns their back, without even trying to make the changes they think it needs, it will never become the website they want.
if Iit werent for people chatting there would be no forum . this was a liveely debate and to be fair.....plenty people had lots to say here.Forums tend to be about exchanging views/talking/chatting, but that is not the sole purpose of Camera Craniums. First and foremost, it is about photography, or it would have been called Chat Companions, or Chattering Chipmunks or something similar.
I'm not posting much because I'm not taking many pictures. I've been rather preoccuppied with my musical interests of late, not least because the weather has been so rubbish. I'm happy for anyone to say anything they like about anything I post - it's all fair game after all . . .
Quote from: Hinfrance on May 02, 2014, 07:05:32 PM
I'm not posting much because I'm not taking many pictures. I've been rather preoccuppied with my musical interests of late, not least because the weather has been so rubbish. I'm happy for anyone to say anything they like about anything I post - it's all fair game after all . . .
Yep, you said it before. Fair game etc.
Hope the weather cheers up soon, or maybe not, as your music ranks just above your photography, doesn't it?