I've noticed on another forum (you know the one), in the critique section people have started downloading other peoples shots, doing some different PPing and then reposting saying isn't that better!!
As far as I can see the original poster never gave any permission.
Is that just wrong?? or am I missing the point of the critique section? ???
Quote from: michaelb104 on April 11, 2011, 12:54:01 PM
I've noticed on another forum (you know the one), in the critique section people have started downloading other peoples shots, doing some different PPing and then reposting saying isn't that better!!
As far as I can see the original poster never gave any permission.
Is that just wrong?? or am I missing the point of the critique section? ???
In my opinion it is wrong if permission is not sort first! Apart from breach of © regardless of whether the image is watermarked; Copyright exists. :beer:
The "I took the liberty of" act, is partly the reason I left a site (beyond those already realised). If the moderators don't police and some members ignore the T&C to apparent applaud :uglystupid2: situations will always arrive.
Such is life - some folk enjoy that behaviour and shead it onto the streets when youngsters copy the arrogant example from the 18+ year olds? as seen online :(
The Internet effects us all in the end :o
I guess when a tot kicks their walking frame away in the time to come, that's when they will awake :legit:
I agree that if someone starts editing a photo without being asked or asking and getting agreement it is a liberty and have never understood those that have the nerve to do so and post it back expecting praise / thanks. Plain rude for me
I guess some folk think it is a "virtual world" on the Internet .
Wait until someone borrows their car and returns it after a bit of Post Processing :knuppel2: :2funny: Same principle! ;)
The piccy is the property of the tog :tup:
Now where's the bar :beer:
I've noticed this happening and assumed that permission had been given via a pm perhaps.
To do it off the cuff is to say the least a liberty and at the worst downright rude. The people that are guilty seem to be newcomers, not just to the forum, but to photography and perhaps have no idea that what they are doing is a breach, not just of copyright, but etiquette.
etiquette ; I'll :beer: to that :tup:
Unless given permission it is wrong .
Some forums have an ' Edit my photo .... Ask me first ' I always opt for ask me first .
If you cross out ask me first then you are giving them permission.
Frankly I don't think any one should tamper with any ones' photo except the person who owns it
Or in a Critique forum where you have asked fo help and they show you how then you do it your self. If you take the a copy of the photo they have used for demonstration., you have your self to live with
I don't know the forum you mean
What has happened to my avatar :'(
I'm glad it's not only me that thinks it's rude.
Alan, you may be right, they might have asked permission by PM first but if not >:(
It's wrong and very bad manners. I've noticed that some do it and say they will delete it if requested to do so, but I think you should ask first regardless. ???
Too many people think they know better
Can't say I've followed any of the posts on that "critique section" Been taking a back seat since they drafted in more moderators. After over three years of moderating it by myself, I've put myself on stand by. lol..
Could you point me to some example posts in that thread please. I'll take a look. ;)
Quote from: admin on April 12, 2011, 09:51:17 AM
Could you point me to some example posts in that thread please. I'll take a look. ;)
After a quick look here is one I found
http://www.photoradar.com/forums/showthread.php?t=5404 (http://www.photoradar.com/forums/showthread.php?t=5404)
All seems very polite though.
It's the manner and the intentions that decides whether or not it is rude.
To critique a photo for a new photographer by just saying to adjust the curves, and crop it a bit doesn't give the full description of what potential might exist. A picture is worth a 1000 words.
When I was starting out with digital photography all those years ago on the DCM forum, when the world was fuzzy, soft and warm and the 1 star trolling hadn't started, I appreciated such help as I hadn't even begun to play with digital editing. At that point, I was mostly accepting what I could get out of the camera JPG images alone. A few of the more experienced members at the time did just this with some of my shots, and it was an eye opener as to what can be achieved. Obviously, if a good explanation as to how the results were achieved was provided then the learning process was much quicker. (I particularly remember some very helpful assistance from craftysnapper)
So if you post in a critique (loosely translated as "what can I do to improve this image") forum, then some leeway or benefit of the doubt has to be provided to the responders. Otherwise the poster won't fully understand or appreciate what the responder might be suggesting. Of course there are always those that post in such forums that are only expecting smoke to be blown up their sphincters and have their egos pumped - but those are usually quickly identified and ignored.
To do this with a shot from someone's gallery where critiques had not been actively sought is exceptionally poor manners.
I'm always happy to hear another interpretation(*) of my own photos, it's part of the learning process.
In summary: these forums are a form of communication, and all forms of communications are fraught with misunderstandings. People need to offer the benefit of the doubt more often than not.
H.
(*) admittedly, there are some people out there who's opinions mean more to me than others...
Quote from: admin on April 12, 2011, 09:51:17 AM
Can't say I've followed any of the posts on that "critique section" Been taking a back seat since they drafted in more moderators. After over three years of moderating it by myself, I've put myself on stand by. lol..
They have? You wouldn't know it.
What Hugh said - I honestly can't see a problem.
I uploaded a pic to a forum and somebody "kindly" edited it for me. I got a call from a friend who was almost literally choking with laughter at the edit (not just because it was bad but by chance it was in a style I hate). But I can't see how it would have annoyed anybody.
As for infringing copyright. Yeah, whatever.... ;) IMO there's such a huge difference between somebody lifting a pic from your site without permission and selling teatowels of it and making an artistic edit in a critique thread that it's silly to call them the same thing. Kind of like saying that stopping kids wearing offensive T shirts to school is a breach of their human rights.
BTW a mate who's an IP lawyer says we all need to stop talking about "breaches" of copyright. It's an infringement. And apparently the legal difference is h-u-g-e.
It`s not "infringement" or "breach" of any copyright that I object to - just bad manners. I would (and have) taken a dim view of anyone editing any of my pics without me requesting or agreeing to it having been asked. You have been warned >:(
I now expect that any shot I upload will be edited to destruction by some joker :)
Quote from: jinky on April 13, 2011, 08:28:28 AM
It`s not "infringement" or "breach" of any copyright that I object to - just bad manners. I would (and have) taken a dim view of anyone editing any of my pics without me requesting or agreeing to it having been asked. You have been warned >:(
I now expect that any shot I upload will be edited to destruction by some joker :)
So it's ok if it's a humorous edit? :)
Quote from: michaelb104 on April 12, 2011, 12:03:17 PM
Quote from: admin on April 12, 2011, 09:51:17 AM
Could you point me to some example posts in that thread please. I'll take a look. ;)
After a quick look here is one I found
http://www.photoradar.com/forums/showthread.php?t=5404 (http://www.photoradar.com/forums/showthread.php?t=5404)
All seems very polite though.
IMHO the edit is worse than the original. I'd have gone for more of a silhouette look. Still, the OP seemed to like it.
H.
Quote from: hevans on April 13, 2011, 08:58:53 AM
Quote from: jinky on April 13, 2011, 08:28:28 AM
It`s not "infringement" or "breach" of any copyright that I object to - just bad manners. I would (and have) taken a dim view of anyone editing any of my pics without me requesting or agreeing to it having been asked. You have been warned >:(
I now expect that any shot I upload will be edited to destruction by some joker :)
So it's ok if it's a humorous edit? :)
No I`d still be annoyed if I wasn`t asked or had not requested it - given the signature stuff and my confused reaction I just half expect someone to test me out. That said I`d be a lot more forgiving of someone I know - even virtually - that did it in a genuine attempt to help / take the leak/ share than a total stranger who just thinks they can do a better image than what I saw / developed in my own head.
Quote from: jinky on April 13, 2011, 11:19:39 AM
No I`d still be annoyed if I wasn`t asked or had not requested it - given the signature stuff and my confused reaction I just half expect someone to test me out. That said I`d be a lot more forgiving of someone I know - even virtually - that did it in a genuine attempt to help / take the leak/ share than a total stranger who just thinks they can do a better image than what I saw / developed in my own head.
Exactly, it's all about context and intentions.
H.
Nit if you have all your photos on a disc and have registerd tio your self and kept the package unopened them because that makes them copyright abd will stand good in a law court
I used the term breach generally (just as a breach of the peace is an infringement and legal eagles make money out of terminology ;) )
Seeking permission to handle someone elses property before you do so, is surely only right, correct, polite and respectful to the originator of a work.
Sending image files via post back to yourself, simply varifies an independant 'time log' to clarify when an original work was dated. Although I cannot imagine Picasso sent his originals through the mail :2funny:
The Exif data of a photograph file is effectively an independant time log of the origination of the that digitalised information. Ownership of the original RAW file also clarifies Ownership.
Fighting any case in court over a copyright breach or infringement will always be expensive and relevant to the value of any calculated loss.
Watermarking and minimising the amount of file data by not uploading all the Exif data onto the Internet, is in my humble opinion a smart way to discourage potential theft misuse of your creative work.
I guess it all boils down to percieved values :)
If you check at the Post Office you will find I'm right
If you register a package to your self it is registered and the contents are then registered copy right . but you mustn't open it it has to stay sealed
Quote from: Beryl on April 13, 2011, 07:27:03 PM
If you check at the Post Office you will find I'm right
If you register a package to your self it is registered and the contents are then registered copy right . but you mustn't open it it has to stay sealed
I know you are right Beryl, as I have used the method myself. It fixes the time date aspect by using the PO stamp and if the package remains sealed the contents have not been changed or tampered with, it may well provide the basis in protection in relation to copyright infringement.
What I was effectively saying is that - The camera and computer effectively automatically and independantly fix the time date of a work. E-mailing files to yourself (so the ISP is effectively the PO stamp) would also fix another independant date process. And in copyright establishing who came up with the material in question in the first place is what it is all about.; Remembering nothing is foolproof, but if one party has a relevant untampered RAW and the other party has only a .tif the untampered file will probably have the upper hand.
In taking most shots, your normally take more than one picture therefore, that's your proof. :dance:
Yes that's true. I have about about 500 discs with most of my origenal photos on ;D
Quote from: Beryl on April 13, 2011, 11:33:14 PM
Yes that's true. I have about about 500 discs with most of my origenal photos on ;D
Hope you still have them backed up to a harddrive. :doh:
Quote from: Beryl on April 13, 2011, 01:48:20 PM
Nit if you have all your photos on a disc and have registerd tio your self and kept the package unopened them because that makes them copyright abd will stand good in a law court
That was a method used by writers to prove they thought of stuff before a film company ripped them off. I guess it would still work though note this doesn't make them copyright - it provides evidence you originated them. As others mention, there are lots of other ways to confirm you originated them.
For example, a "photographer" recently ripped off a load of pics from a site. Not only were they so far from the standard of his work it was obvious, the subject of one of them could categorically say "you were not standing in front of me with a camera". And she did. Quite loudly. :)