Camera Craniums: The Photography Community for Enthusiasts

General Category => General Discussion => Topic started by: Hinfrance on December 12, 2010, 09:48:32 AM

Title: 3D Cinema
Post by: Hinfrance on December 12, 2010, 09:48:32 AM
Just wondered, out of curiosity, what others think of this?

Out here in the sticks we finally have a 3D equiped cinema, and last evening I saw my first of the current generation of 3D films - it was Narnia, Voyage of the Dawntreader.

I was completely underwhelmed by the 3D effect. For me it was like watching a film in the style of ViewMaster - depth between various characters and objects was clearly discernible, but each 'layer' as it were was distinctly flat. I yearned to see the 2D version so that, as in the real world, my brain could process my stereoscopic vision to add the natural depth I usually see. Add to this the fact that after an hour the glasses became physically uncomfortable and we have a cinema experience somewhat inferior to the old fashioned 2D version.

My good lady is one of the 5% or so of unfortunate people who cannot see the effect at all. My daughter enjoyed it enormously, but mainly for the content, not the 3D.

I am not against the idea of 3D cinema per se - the Imax 3D films shown at Futuroscope are truly wonderful, but flat screen 3D cinema was completely different and very disappointing in comparison.

I understand that Megamind is supposed to be an example of 3D done well, so I'll go to see that when it turns up in our backwater later this month.

I see one critic had this to say about the film "I'm afraid it's in 3-D. I will say it has the best rendition of 3-D I've seen in one of these action spectaculars; Apted uses it and is not driven by it. The light level is dimmed. It always is in 3-D. I wish I could have seen it in 2-D. If you can, try to." That sums up my feelings.