Camera Craniums: The Photography Community for Enthusiasts

General Category => General Photography => Topic started by: Verb on January 26, 2010, 03:28:00 PM

Title: I can't decide which one is better
Post by: Verb on January 26, 2010, 03:28:00 PM
Help!! I can't decide which one I prefer, I'm leaning towards the latter

This one which is edited in Photoshop:
(http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4054/4305896341_477d8fbf2b.jpg)

Or this one that I put through photomatix:
(http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4009/4306102871_d1623c6c42.jpg)

Opinions please :)
Title: Re: I can't decide which one is better
Post by: Forseti on January 26, 2010, 03:30:32 PM
For me the second although I'm sure you could have achieved the same effect in Photoshop.
Title: Re: I can't decide which one is better
Post by: picsfor on January 26, 2010, 03:50:35 PM
You could have achieved the same effect in LR as well as Photoshop.
Given your earlier comments re an angry man - i would go with the second because it conveys a darker and so more menacing perspective.
Title: Re: I can't decide which one is better
Post by: Verb on January 26, 2010, 03:55:01 PM
I know I could have achieved the same effect in LR or Photoshop, it's just I used Photomatix to do it lol  :tup:

Thanks guys  :beer:
Title: Re: I can't decide which one is better
Post by: ABERS on January 26, 2010, 04:42:32 PM
Just to be awkward, the top head would have looked better on the bottom body.
The top body is too light and dominates the overall scheme of things, and the bottom head loses too much detail detail in the shadows at the left side.
Title: Re: I can't decide which one is better
Post by: Graham on January 26, 2010, 04:42:44 PM
   For me, the second one, but I would do a square crop of the top end as I find the gent's cardigan a bit of a distraction.
               Like the pic though.   Graham.

Title: Re: I can't decide which one is better
Post by: Verb on January 26, 2010, 04:52:15 PM
(http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4046/4306282081_d59176d276.jpg)

I think you may be right Graham, thanks
Title: Re: I can't decide which one is better
Post by: SimonW on January 26, 2010, 06:09:13 PM
Difficult! I agree the original has too much cardigan, but take the square shot with a little more off each side and (ignoring the exposure) you get a perfect passport photo. Probably not the effect you wanted.

I've got three RAW processors - Silkypix came with the camera (Pentax), Paint Shop Pro and Adobe, and they all appear to give differing results. They all do a good job though their tools are quite different, and I can't say I prefer the results from any particular one. I've tried several times, for interest's sake, to reproduce the exact appearance of a photo "developed" in one of them with the same RAW file in one of the others, without success.

If we're voting on the originals my own preference is for the top one because it's slightly lighter.